3654 Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 147 (10) 3654-3660 (2000)
S0013-4651(00)02-083-8 CCC: $7.00 © The Electrochemical Society, Inc.
When a painted steel sheet is cut at the factory, the bare metal is
exposed in cross section on the cut edge, where it becomes a corro-
sion risk regardless of the barrier properties of the paint layer on the
face. Such “cut edge corrosion” is a well known problem particular
to coil coated steel products
1,2
and may represent a major, but large-
ly ignored, obstacle to the development of advanced on-line coating
technologies such as plasma polymerization. Therefore, there is an
immediate interest in understanding the corrosion protection mech-
anisms which are provided by the coating layers against this form of
corrosion.
In a more general way, corrosion on the cut edge of galvanized
steel products can be considered as a worst case scenario for sacrifi-
cial protection by zinc coatings, because of the very unfavorable
anode to cathode surface area ratio. The zinc layer is on the order of
5 to 20 mm thick as compared to around 800 to 1000 mm for the steel
substrate. Therefore secondary mechanisms of protection involving
the formation of protective films from zinc corrosion products and
from water soluble inhibitors in the paint
2,3
play an important role on
the cut edge of coil coated steel.
The efficiency of chemical inhibition is highly dependent on the
chemical and electrochemical environment which is found in the
vicinity of the cut edge. The strong galvanic couple set up between
the steel and the zinc leads to large electrical field variations, and the
close proximity of the anodic and cathodic reactions leads to signif-
icant changes in the chemical environment including increases in
[OH
2
] and [Zn
12
]. The distribution of current is further altered by
the precipitation of zinc-based corrosion products and the release of
water soluble inhibitors present in the paint. Although extensive ana-
lytical studies on the nature of the corrosion products have been un-
dertaken in recent years,
4-7
their role in inhibiting the electrochemi-
cal reactions has been given much less attention.
In this work, we have used in situ electrochemical techniques
with local resolution, the scanning vibrating electrode technique
(SVET) and scanning pH microscopy, to investigate the interrela-
tionship between electrochemical activity, pH changes, and corro-
sion-product precipitation. In particular, localized polarization
curves were obtained for the anodic and cathodic reactions in order
to determine the rate-limiting processes on the cut edge and to ob-
serve the inhibiting effect of corrosion products. Preliminary results
have been previously presented concerning the polarization behav-
ior
8,9
and localized pH measurements
10
on the cut edge.
Experimental
Sample preparation and model sample design.—Cut edge phe-
nomena were simulated in the laboratory by embedding, in an epoxy
resin, a commercial electrogalvanized low alloy carbon steel sample
typical of that used in the automotive industry. The cut edge was
exposed in cross section to form an electroactive area of 10 3
0.81 mm. The steel thickness was approximately 800 mm, and the
zinc coating ranged from 5 to 10 mm. The cut edge surface was pol-
ished to a 1 mm finish and particular care was taken during polish-
ing to avoid spreading the zinc onto the steel surface. Single and
double sided electrogalvanized steel were used as indicated in the
text. Electrogalvanized steel was chosen for this work because of its
high level of purity and reproducibility as an industrial product.
For galvanic coupling experiments, a model cut edge sample was
prepared. This consisted of separate steel and zinc samples mounted
in the epoxy resin with approximately 2 mm of separation between
them. A 250 mm zinc foil (Goodfellow, 99.95
1
%) and a sample of
low alloy carbon steel of 800 mm thickness, were used. The edges of
the sample were exposed to the electrolyte and the two metals were
short-circuited by an external circuit.
The large-area Zn/steel electrode was prepared by vapor deposit-
ing a 5 mm thick Zn coating over one-third of a 5 3 10 mm low alloy
carbon steel electrode. The deposition was done by masking the sur-
face not to be coated by an adhesive tape (3M PTFE 5490, based on
a silicone adhesive with upper temperature limit of 2048C), which
was removed after the zinc deposition. The sample was sputtered
with Ar ions before the deposition of the zinc in order to increase the
metal/metal adherence. This sample was stored in a dissicator prior
to use. The electrodes thus produced were exposed to NaCl solutions
of variable concentration as described in the text. Because of a poor
Zn to steel adherence, the electrodes were not submitted to any addi-
tional cleaning regime. All solutions used deionized water (>5 MV-
cm) and reagent grade NaCl. The electrolytes were aerated, and all
experiments were conducted at ambient temperature.
Current density measurements.—A commercial SVET system
from Applicable Electronics was used in this work.
11,12
The probe
consisted of an insulated Pt-Ir wire with a Pt black deposit at the tip
on the order of 20 mm diam. The probe is vibrated at different fre-
quencies in the parallel and perpendicular direction to the surface,
with an amplitude on the order of 20 to 40 mm. The two-dimension-
al (2D) vibration is accomplished by use of piezoelectric wafers dri-
ven by sinewave oscillators. The parallel and perpendicular compo-
nents of the local electric field are considered proportional to the
parellel and perpendicular components of the current vector, J
x
and
J
z
, and are measured by independent lock-in amplifiers. The second
horizontal component of current, J
y
, is not measured with this sys-
tem. The calibration parameters necessary to convert the electric
field data into current were determined from a one-point calibration,
performed by taking a measurement at a fixed distance from a point
Localized Electrochemical Methods Applied to Cut Edge Corrosion
K. Ogle,*
,z
V. Baudu, L. Garrigues, and X. Philippe
Irsid, Usinor Research, 57283 Maizières-lès-Metz, France
Current density and pH mapping techniques have been used to characterize the chemical and electrochemical phenomena which
occur on the cut edge of galvanized steel. pH variations between 7 and 11 were observed, primarily due to the formation of hydrox-
yl ions by the cathodic reaction. Zinc-based corrosion products precipitated in zones of intermediate pH were identified as ZnO
and 3Zn(OH)
2
?2ZnCO
3
for model samples. The efficiency of these corrosion products as cathodic inhibitors was demonstrated by
the absence of cathodic activity at open circuit and a 2300 mV negative shift of the onset potential for hydrogen formation in the
affected zones. The cathodic current, localized over the steel, was independent of potential, consistent with a diffusion-limited
reduction of oxygen. The anodic current, localized over the zinc, varied with potential, with a Tafel slope of 44 mV/decade for an
order of magnitude decrease of potential below open circuit. The addition of SrCrO
4
to the electrolyte increased the Tafel slope to
63 mV/decade, consistent with a passivating inhibitor on the anode surface.
© 2000 The Electrochemical Society. S0013-4651(00)02-083-8. All rights reserved.
Manuscript submitted February 22, 2000; revised manuscript received May 19, 2000. This was in part Paper 582 presented at the
Honolulu, Hawaii, Meeting of the Society, October 17-22, 1999.
* Electrochemical Society Active Member.
z
E-mail: kevin.ogle@irsid.usinor.com