Int Arch f)rcn Fnvirnn Tepnlth ( 1 Q 99 Q 6420 Q 9-15
. ~~'1 |_ 11 ~ ~ W 9 Wl J II~VIISI 111 · b "V J / Intemtional Archivesof
t U Ipalionalufd
Environmental
Health
© Springer-Verlag 1992
Chromosome aberrations and micronuclei in lymphocytes
of workers exposed to low and medium levels of styrene
R Tomanin
l
, C Ballarin, G B Bartolucci
l
, E De Rosa
2
, G Sessa
3
, G Iannini
4
, A R Cupiraggi
4
, and F Sarto
5
'Institute of Occupational Health, University of Padova, Via Facciolati 71, I-35127 Padova, Italy
2
Chair of Occupational Health, University of Ferrara, Italy
3
Occupational Health Inspectorate (S M P I L ), U L S S 32, Portomaggiore, Ferrara, Italy
4 Occupational Health Inspectorate (S M P I L), U L S S 20, Casalecchio sul Reno, Bologna, Italy
5 Occupational Health Inspectorate (S P I S A L), U L S S 21, Padova, Italy
Received November 29, 1991 / Accepted May 8, 1992
Summary In the present study we analysed 19 workers
exposed to styrene in two factories where polyester
resins were used Because of the different sizes of the
pieces undergoing resin processing, the environmental
styrene concentrations and urinary mandelic acid (MA)
levels of the analysed subjects were quite different in the
two plants examined Cytogenetic monitoring was per-
formed by analysis of chromosome aberrations (C As)
and micronuclei (Mn) in peripheral blood lymphocytes.
Cytogenetic analysis revealed a significant increase in
the percentage of aberrant cells and total aberrations in
the group with higher styrene exposure (group 2) and no
increase in the group with lower exposure (group 1), as
compared with matched controls Mn frequencies were
not significantly increased in the two exposed popula-
tions No correlations between length of exposure and
CA or Mn frequency were found, and a weak correlation
was found between exposure levels, measured as urinary
MA, and Mn frequencies Only 5 of the 12 exposed
workers examined in group 2 had urinary MA levels
higher than the limit recommended by the ACGIH in
1990-91 l 1 l Significant increases in DNA damage are
therefore already found at urinary MA levels lower than
the internationally suggested exposure limits.
Key words: Chromosome aberrations Micronuclei -
Peripheral blood lymphocytes Styrene
Introduction
Cytogenetic monitoring of human exposure to styrene in
the work environment has been widely evaluated in past
years by using both chromosome aberration (CA) and
sister chromatid exchange (SCE) l 2, 4, 8-10, 12, 13,
15-18, 20, 23, 26, 28, 30 l and, more recently, by micro-
nucleus (Mn) analysis l 8, 11, 15, 16, 20 l Since 1977, the
year in which the first cytogenetic analysis of exposed
Correspondence to: R Tomanin
workers was published l 17 l, several other studies show-
ing contradictory results on the cytogenetic effects of
styrene have been reported About 50 % of these have
noted a significant increase in the frequency of one or
more of the cytogenetic parameters evaluated l 2, 4, 7,
11, 16-18, 30 l In general, although a significant in-
crease in damage in the exposed subjects with respect to
controls was not necessarily found, the data in the litera-
ture reveal a relationship between exposure levels and
presence of induced damage, the environmental thresh-
old limit of 50 ppm ( 215 mg/m
3
) still being critical.
Human exposure to styrene is usually evaluated by
measuring the urinary concentrations of mandelic and
phenylglyoxylic acids l 3 l which, however, should only be
considered as indicators of very recent exposure l 5 l
while cytogenetic endpoints may represent indicators of
long-term exposure.
With reference to the biological exposure index
(BEI) adopted by the ACGIH l 1 l, the urinary mandelic
acid (MA) level considered acceptable is 800 mg/g
creatinine However, significant increases in the cyto-
genetic parameters evaluated in the present work were
found in the literature at far lower exposure levels than
the established limit A significant increase in C As has
already been found at mean urinary MA concentrations
of less than 500 mg/g creatinine l 4, 10, 18 l.
In the present study, two small groups of workers ex-
posed to two different levels of styrene were examined:
urinary MA levels and frequencies of C As and Mn in
peripheral blood lymphocytes were estimated Mn anal-
ysis was performed by the cytochalasin B-block method
l 6 l, with modifications.
Materials and methods
Subjects and work environment
The workers analysed in the present study were employed in two
factories where polyester resins were used: the first produced small
fiberglass tanks and the second, fiberglass boats.
For both exposed groups, a control group matched for sex, age
and smoking habits was also analysed for CA and Mn frequencies.