Water Qual. Res. J. Canada, 2006 • Volume 41, No. 4, 410–417
Copyright © 2006, CAWQ
410
Performance of Laboratory-Scale Wetlands Planted with
Tropical Ornamental Plants to Treat Domestic Wastewater
Florentina Zurita,
1
Jose de Anda
2
* and Marco A. Belmont
3
1
Centro Universitario de la Ciénega, Universidad de Guadalajara, Av. Universidad 1115, Ocotlán, Jalisco, Mexico
2
Centro de Investigación y Asistencia en Tecnología y Diseño del Estado de Jalisco, A. C. Normalistas 800,
44270 Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico
3
Wetland Biogeochemistry Institute, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, Louisiana, United States 70803
This work proposes an innovative wastewater treatment system that consists of a constructed subsurface flow wetland
planted with ornamental flowers of high market value. In addition to the benefit of the water treatment, this cash crop pro-
vides a profitable business by producing commercial flowers that can meet all biological and safety requirements in order to
be commercialized. This characteristic of the treatment system makes it very valuable for application in developing countries.
Five different species of ornamental plants were studied from September 2004 to January 2005. Several water quality para-
meters were evaluated at the inlet and outlet of a laboratory-scale system. COD was reduced by more than 75% in all cases;
BOD and nitrogen were removed by more than 70%, except in one cell; phosphorus was reduced by more than 66% and
the dissolved oxygen increased from 0.175 to 5.8 mg L
–1
. Total and fecal coliforms were removed in the wetland by more
than 99.3%. According to these results, it is feasible to couple ornamental flower production with wastewater treatment. A
pilot-scale study is recommended in order to validate the preliminary results under more realistic conditions.
Key words: ornamental plants, constructed wetlands, subsurface wetlands, wastewater treatment, municipal wastewater,
Lake Chapala
* Corresponding author; janda@ciatej.net.mx
Introduction
The world is experiencing significant growth in human
population, and fresh water is becoming a scarce
resource. Lakes represent a major source of such fresh
water, but are coming under increasing pressure through
exploitation by agriculture, industry, drinking water and
hydroelectricity generation. This is particularly the case
in tropical developing countries.
Many authors (Ryding and Rast 1989; Welch 1992;
Maniak 1997) suggest that the most effective long-term
measure for the control of eutrophication in a water body
is the reduction of the input of external nutrients. One
way to reduce the nutrients coming from point sources, is
to remove them by biological treatment. Unfortunately,
the cost of installation and operation of a wastewater
treatment plant (WWTP) does not permit the municipal
governments of developing countries to invest in such
technologies (Kivaisi 2001; Belmont et al. 2004).
Lake Chapala is the most important natural lake in
Mexico and the main fresh water supply for Guadalajara
City. The primary tributary to Lake Chapala is the Lerma
River. Large quantities of domestic, agricultural and
industrial sewage from the entire Lerma-Chapala basin
still flow untreated into the watershed and eventually into
the lake, resulting in excessive inputs of phosphorus (P)
and nitrogen (N), both known to cause eutrophication (de
Anda and Shear 2001). Human water demand from Lake
Chapala surpasses the surface supply and groundwater
recharge rate (de Anda et al. 1998). This has resulted in a
hydrologic imbalance in the lake basin. In addition, high
nutrient concentrations in the lake have led to degraded
water quality, resulting in growth of floating aquatic vege-
tation and blue-green algae. The adverse environmental
impacts are clearly reflected in the considerable reduction
of native and migratory fauna and in the severe reduction
of the water storage volume.
A solution to reduction of the severe environmental
impacts and eutrophication of Lake Chapala is to
develop a cost-effective treatment technology, namely a
constructed subsurface flow wetland (SSFW), which
could permit a significant reduction of nutrient contami-
nation along the Lerma River and around the lake shore.
The proposed treatment system is less expensive than the
existing commercial systems, and is easier to build and
operate (Linsley et al. 1992; Seoánez-Calvo 1999; Kivaisi
2001; Belmont and Metcalfe 2003; Dallas 2004). SSFW
are useful not only for the control of pollution with nutri-
ents but also to remove persistent organic pollutants from
wastewater and runoff (Belmont et al. 2006).
This sewage treatment system allows the develop-
ment of a profitable business by producing commercial
ornamental flowers that meet all biological safety
requirements in order to be delivered to the market.