1
Abstract--With the increasing use of High-Voltage Cables,
which have different electric characteristics from Overhead
Lines, phenomenon like current zero-missing start to appear
more often on the transmission systems. Methods to prevent zero-
missing phenomenon are still being studied and compared to see
which countermeasure works the best. Technically the best way
to avoid zero-missing phenomenon produces very high switching
overvoltages, making the operator to choose to either avoid the
zero-missing phenomenon or to minimize the switching
transients. This paper presents a method of determining an
optimal value of the resistance of the pre-insertion resistor that
results in minimizing both the zero-missing phenomenon and
switching overvoltages simultaneously.
Index Terms--Cables, Circuit Breaker, Pre-Insertion Resistor,
Shunt Reactor, Switching Transients, Level-crossing problems
I. INTRODUCTION
he increase of public pressure regarding the devastation
of areas of natural beauty by Overhead Lines (OHL),
drove to increase demand for the substitution of the OHL by
underground cables.
The Danish Transmission System Operator (Energinet.dk) is
studying a possible expansion of the high-voltage system
using AC underground cables instead of OHL. One of the
problems that must be studied when using systems with
underground cable is zero-missing phenomenon.
Electrically the main difference between an OHL and an
Underground Cable is the much higher capacitance of the last
ones, which can be dozens of times superior to the
capacitance of OHL [2].
Because of this high capacitance, it is required to connect
This work was supported in part by the Danish Transmission System
Operator, Energinet.dk.
F. F. da Silva is a PhD student at the Institute of Energy Technology,
Aalborg University, 9220 Aalborg, Denmark (e-mail:ffs@iet.aau.dk).
C. L. Bak is with the Institute of Energy Technology, Aalborg University,
9220 Aalborg, Demark (e-mail: clb@iet.aau.dk).
U. S. Gudmundsdottir is a PhD student at the Institute of Energy Technology,
Aalborg University, 9220 Aalborg, Denmark (e-mail: usg@iet.aau.dk).
W. Wiechowski is a Senior System Analyst at the Planning Department of
Energinet.dk (e-mail: wwi@energinet.dk)
M. R. Knardrupgård is with the Planning Department of Energinet.dk (e-
mail: mra@energinet.dk)
shunt reactor(s) in parallel to the cables, in order to
compensate the reactive power generated by them.
If the shunt reactors are compensating all the reactive power
generated by the cable, the AC component of the current in
the cable has opposite phase angle to AC component of the
current into the shunt reactors, and therefore they cancel out
each other. As the transient of the shunt’s reactor current
contain both AC and DC components, during transient
conditions (as for instance energization of a cable
compensated with shunt reactors) under ideal conditions only
DC component would remain.
During energizing, the cable has no load and it is open in the
far end. As the resistance of the system (cables+shunt
reactors) is very small, it may take several seconds for the DC
component to be damped. As the current does not cross zero
during those seconds, it is not possible to open the circuit
breaker without risking damaging it, unless it is prepared to
interrupt DC currents or currents with several amperes [3][4].
If in the meanwhile, a single-phase or two-phase fault occurs
on the cable, the circuit breaker will be able to open the
faulted phases but not the healthy phase(s) because of the lack
of zero-crossings of the current. This can leads to a damage of
the circuit breaker.
A method that can be used to damp the DC component in just
half of cycle, is to use circuit breakers equipped with pre-
insertion resistors.
II. ZERO-MISSING PHENOMENON AND SWITCHING
OVERVOLTAGES
An easy way to understand zero-missing phenomenon is to
analyze the transient behaviour of an inductor in parallel with
a capacitor of equal impedance.
In this situation the currents in each one of the elements
have equal amplitude and are in phase opposition. But in
transient conditions the current in the inductor also has a DC
offset, whose value depends on the voltage value at the
connection moment.
There is a 90º difference between the phases of the current
and the voltage in an inductor, therefore if the inductor is
connected in a voltage peak the current should be zero. If it is
connected when the voltage is zero the current should have a
peak value. As the current in the inductor must maintain its
continuity, and it was zero before the connection of the
Use of a Pre-Insertion Resistor to Minimize
Zero-Missing Phenomenon and Switching
Overvoltages
F. Faria da Silva, C. L. Bak, U. S. Guðmundsdóttir, W. Wiechowski and M. R. Knardrupgård
T
978-1-4244-4241-6/09/$25.00 ©2009 IEEE