Research Article
Autistic Traits Affect P300 Response to Unexpected Events,
regardless of Mental State Inferences
Mitsuhiko Ishikawa,
1
Shoji Itakura,
1
and Hiroki C. Tanabe
2
1
Graduate School of Letters, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
2
Graduate School of Environmental Studies, Nagoya University, Nagoya, Japan
Correspondence should be addressed to Mitsuhiko Ishikawa; ishikawa.mitsuhiko.23r@st.kyoto-u.ac.jp
Received 22 December 2016; Revised 18 March 2017; Accepted 9 April 2017; Published 4 June 2017
Academic Editor: Robert F. Berman
Copyright © 2017 Mitsuhiko Ishikawa et al. Tis is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly
cited.
Limited use of contextual information has been suggested as a way of understanding cognition in people with autism spectrum
disorder (ASD). However, it has also been argued that individuals with ASD may have difculties inferring others’ mental states.
Here, we examined how individuals with diferent levels of autistic traits respond to contextual deviations by measuring event-
related potentials that refect context usage. Te Autism Spectrum Quotient (AQ) was used to quantify autistic-like traits in
28 university students, and 19 participants were defned as Low or High AQ groups. To additionally examine inferences about
mental state, two belief conditions (with or without false belief) were included. Participants read short stories in which the fnal
sentence included either an expected or an unexpected word and rated the word’s degree of deviation from expectation. P300
waveform analysis revealed that unexpected words were associated with larger P300 waveforms for the Low AQ group, but smaller
P300 responses in the High AQ group. Additionally, AQ social skill subscores were positively correlated with evaluation times in
the Unexpected condition, whether a character’s belief was false or not. Tis suggests that autistic traits can afect responses to
unexpected events, possibly because of decreased availability of context information.
1. Introduction
Tere is a general assumption that, in order to interact with
and have smooth relationships with others in society, one
must master certain social behaviors such as empathizing
with others, understanding humour, seeing through lies, and
comprehending ironies. A diagnosis of autism spectrum dis-
order (ASD) indicates difculties with these social behaviors,
which are required for understanding others’ beliefs, desires,
and intentions (termed “theory of mind” [1]).
It has been argued that the foundation of social difculties
may be the absence of a theory of mind [2]. However, Happ´ e
[3] revealed that children with ASD can obtain a theory of
mind, albeit with some developmental delay. Subsequently,
explanations for problems associated with ASD began to
focus on the ways that theory of mind is used in social
situations. One such explanation involves the idea of context
blindness [4], which, for people with ASD, refers to difcul-
ties with the spontaneous use of context in social situations.
For instance, to accurately appraise emotions based on
another person’s facial expressions, we must think about con-
textual information, such as the events afecting or surround-
ing the person. Additionally, understanding irony and sar-
casm depends heavily on context. Tere is an example in the
Strange Stories test that assesses theory of mind [4]: Emma
takes a banana, holds it against her ear, and then says “Look,
this banana is a telephone!” In this story, what Emma said is
not literally true, but we can understand through context that
it is about pretending. Terefore, the use of theory of mind
in social situations may be related to the spontaneous use of
contextual information.
For the purposes of the context blindness hypothesis,
context is defned as not only the fow of linguistic informa-
tion, but also any type of global information, including that
based on visual perceptual. Te frst global hypothesis states
that weak central coherence (WCC [5, 6]) explains defcits in
the use of global information in people with ASD. Tis theory
asserts that people with ASD are not inclined to perceive
Hindawi
Autism Research and Treatment
Volume 2017, Article ID 8195129, 10 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/8195129