Research Article
Designing an Intuitionistic Fuzzy Network Data Envelopment
Analysis Model for Efficiency Evaluation of Decision-Making
Units with Two-Stage Structures
Nafiseh Javaherian ,
1
Ali Hamzehee ,
1
and Hossein Sayyadi Tooranloo
2
1
Department of Applied Mathematics, Kerman Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kerman, Iran
2
Department of Management, Meybod University, Meybod, Iran
CorrespondenceshouldbeaddressedtoAliHamzehee;hamzehee_ali@yahoo.com
Received 26 June 2020; Revised 6 October 2020; Accepted 18 December 2020; Published 7 January 2021
AcademicEditor:JoseA.Sanz
Copyright©2021NafisehJavaherianetal.isisanopenaccessarticledistributedundertheCreativeCommonsAttribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Data envelopment analysis (DEA) is a powerful tool for evaluating the efficiency of decision-making units for ranking and
comparisonpurposesandtodifferentiateefficientandinefficientunits.ClassicDEAmodelsareill-suitedfortheproblemswhere
decision-makingunitsconsistofmultiplestageswithintermediateproductsandthosewhereinputsandoutputsareimpreciseor
nondeterministic,whichisnotuncommonintherealworld.ispaperpresentsanewDEAmodelforevaluatingtheefficiencyof
decision-makingunitswithtwo-stagestructuresandtriangularintuitionisticfuzzydata.epaperfirstintroducestwo-stageDEA
models,thenexplainshowthesemodelscanbemodifiedwithintuitionisticfuzzycoefficients,andfinallydescribeshowarithmetic
operatorsforintuitionisticfuzzynumberscanbeusedforaconversionintocrisptwo-stagestructures.Intheend,theproposed
method is used to solve an illustrative numerical example.
1.Introduction
Data envelopment analysis is a standard quantitative tool
withextensiveuseinefficiencyevaluationsandperformance
analysis [1]. DEA measures the relative efficiency of deci-
sion-makingunits(DMUs)withsimilarinputsandoutputs
in order to give an estimation of how efficient a unit is in
comparison with other units [2–4].
However, most of the commonly used DEA models are
criticized for treating units as black boxes and ignoring their
internal processes, the efficiency of these processes, and their
relationships[5,6].isblackboxapproachcausestheanalysis
tomissalotofvaluableinformationaboutDMUsandlimitsits
scope to the fundamental inputs and the ultimate outputs [7].
To address this issue, F¨ areet al. [8] introduced network data
envelopment analysis (NDEA) and explained its importance
for having a more accurate efficiency analysis of DMUs.
Unlike traditional DEA models, NDEA models have no
fixedformulationandcanbedevelopedintodifferentforms
based on the type of process and network structure [9].
NDEA can very well illustrate the relationships and inter-
dependencies between internal processes and accurately
calculatetheoverallefficiencyaswellastheefficiencyineach
stage [3, 10]. In addition, this method can be used for ac-
curate tracking of the sources of inefficiency in inefficient
units [11]. e two-stage network structure is one of the
NDEA topologies that has been extensively studied by re-
searchers [12–15].
Typically, data in DEA models are crisp and deter-
ministic, but given the high frequency of uncertainties in
real-world problems and impreciseness in real-world data,
onesimplycannotdependonclassicalmathematicstosolve
theseproblems.esolutiontothisissueistousethegray
dimensionofclassicallogic,whichisfuzzylogic,toimprove
theresultsofthemodels.etheoryoffuzzysets,whichisan
extended version of crisp sets, was first proposed by Zadeh
[16], originally with the purpose of developing a more ef-
ficient model for use in natural language processing.
Hindawi
Advances in Fuzzy Systems
Volume 2021, Article ID 8860634, 15 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/8860634