International Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Robotics Research Vol. 9, No. 1, January 2020
© 2020 Int. J. Mech. Eng. Rob. Res 130
doi: 10.18178/ijmerr.9.1.130-135
Performance Evaluation of Solar Receiver Heat
Exchanger with Rectangular-Wing Vortex
Generators
Narin Koolnapadol
Department of Automotive Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Industrial Technology,
Rajabhat Rajanagarindra University, Chachoengsao 24000, Thailand
Pongjet Promvonge
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering,
King Mongkut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang, Bangkok 10520, Thailand
Sompol Skullong*
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering at Sriracha,
Kasetsart University Sriracha Campus, 199 M.6, Sukhumvit Rd., Sriracha, Chonburi 20230, Thailand
E-mail: sfengsps@src.ku.ac.th, sompol@eng.src.ku.ac.th
Abstract—The paper presents an experimental investigation
on heat transfer and flow resistance in a solar air heater
(SAH) duct with rectangular-wing vortex generators
(RWVGs) on the absorber plate to increase the SAH system
performance. The experimental work is carried out in the
test duct with its aspect ratio (AR) of 10 for Reynolds
number (Re) based on the hydraulic duct diameter ranging
from 5290 to 22,700. The RWVGs are placed on the
absorber with three attack angles ( ° ° and 60°) and
three relative wing pitches (P
R
= P
l
/H = 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0) at a
single relative wing height (B
R
=b/H=0.67). The experimental
result shows that the use of RWVGs leads to the
considerable increase in Nusselt number (Nu) over the flat-
plate duct (smooth duct) around 4.06–5.79 times while the
increase in friction factor (f) is about 11.43–43.97 times. The
Nu and f display the increasing trend with the rise of but
show the opposite trend for the increment of P
R
. The highest
thermal performance for using the RWVG roughness is
some 1.95 at ° and P
R
= 1.5. Correlations for Nu and f
have also been developed and determined as a function of
RWVG parameters.
Index Terms—solar air heater, vortex generators, flow
resistance, thermal performance
I. INTRODUCTION
To achieve renewable and clean energy, several solar
energy/power technologies are under development and
some can produce electric power by converting sunlight
into thermal energy at high temperature of gas/steam to
obtain the turbine work for electrical generator. However,
the efficiency or performance of the current solar
plants/solar thermal systems is not high. It has been
suggested that the potential way to increase the thermal
performance of solar thermal systems is to introduce a
Manuscript received July 28, 2018; revised August 15, 2019.
vortex generator (VG) device. VG devices in the form of
ribs [1,2], fins [3], baffles [4], winglets [5,6] and wings [7]
are passive elements widely used to enhance the rate of
heat transfer in various thermal systems. VG devices
provide excess heat transfer area to fluid streams which
results in the rate of heat transfer. Earlier investigations
have been conducted to study the effect of VG devices on
heat transfer enhancement in the heat exchanger/solar air
heater systems [8-11]. The effect of rib size and
arrangement on turbulent heat transfer and flow friction
characteristics in a solar air heater channel was
experimentally investigated by Skullong et al. [12], while
the thermal and flow resistance in a square duct fitted
diagonally with angle-finned tapes were studied
experimentally and numerically by Promvonge et al.
[13,14]. Tamna et al. [15] examined thermal performance
enhancement in a solar air heater (SAH) channel with
multiple V-baffle vortex generators (BVG) and
concluded that the single BVG with PR = 0.5 yields the
highest thermal performance. Skullong et al. [16] also
investigated thermal behaviors in a SAH channel using
wavy grooves incorporated with pairs of trapezoidal-
winglets (TW) placed on the absorber plate and found
that the highest thermal performance was obtained for the
wavy-groove in common with the TW at P
R
= 1 and B
R
=
0.24. The effect of delta-wing vortex generators located
at the leading edge of a flat plate on heat transfer
behaviors was reported by Gentry and Jacobi [17].
Following the above literature review, the utilization of
winglets/wings has been found to give more attractive
than other VG devices due to lower pressure loss. In
general, winglets/wings are designed to create
longitudinal vortices that can help increase turbulence
levels leading to improvement of the rate of heat transfer,
albeit with a minimal pressure loss penalty. However, the
winglets/wings cited above, in general, have been widely
used to improve the thermal performance of fin-tube heat