Vol. 22, May/June 2010 Journal of Essential Oil Research/283
Received: May 2008
Revised: September 2008
Accepted: November 2008
Effect of Some Essential Oils as Natural Food
Preservatives on Commercial Grated Carrots
Flora V. Romeo, Serena De Luca, Amalia Piscopo, Emanuela De Salvo and Marco Poiana,*
BIOMAA - Department of Biotechnologies for Agricultural Food and Environmental Monitoring, Mediterranean
University of Reggio Calabria, Feo di Vito 89060 (RC), Italy
Abstract
In the present work, the effects of lemon verbena (Lippia citriodora), cypress (Cupressus sempervirens) and
lemon-balm (Melissa officinalis) essential oils against the growth of three microorganisms (potentially dangerous to
the safety of foods) were evaluated. The three oils were chosen and tested on grated carrots inoculated with bacteria
and stored at 8°C until 8 days to simulate the market sale. The most resistant of the three strains against all the tested
oils was Escherichia coli, while Listeria strain was the most easily influenced. An important interaction was revealed
with the packaging type: oxygen diffusion greatly influenced the bacteria survival at the end of the experiment.
Key Word Index
Carrots, Melissa officinalis, Lamiaceae, Lippia citriodora, Verbenaceae, Cupressus sempervirens, Cupressaceae,
essential oil composition, a-pinene, d-3-carene, citronellal, geranial, neral, preservatives.
1041-2905/10/0003-0283$14.00/0—© 2010 Allured Business Media
*Address for correspondence
Introduction
There has been considerable emphasis on studies involving
essential oils, extracts and decoctions of spices on inhibiting the
growth of microbes (1). Examinations of the growth-inhibitory
effects of essential oil components on microorganisms has been
studied (2). In fact, many authors have reported antimicrobial,
antifungal, antioxidant and radical-scavenging properties of
spices and oils (3).
The bacteria Listeria monocytogenes, Staphylococcus au-
reus and Escherichia coli are important foodborne pathogens
because of their ability to grow at a wide range of temperature,
pH and high salt content. Since Listeria spp. is an ubiquitous
microorganism, post-process contamination of cooked product
is a major concern and has been reported during the packaging
stage of production (4). Some components of oils can be used
as antilisterial materials; most of this antimicrobial activity
appears to derive from phenolic compounds (5).
It has been shown that some pathogens are able to survive
and grow to significant numbers on refrigerated foods (6),
thus making post-process contamination a significant concern.
Moreover, the problem of preserving food is becoming more
complex, with the introduction of new products requiring an
even longer shelf-life and a higher degree of protection against
pathogenic microorganisms (7). Fruits and vegetables are eco-
logical niches for a diverse and changing microflora. Fresh raw
produce contains a complex mix of bacteria, fungi and yeasts
that are characteristic of that fruit or vegetable, and whose
population and kinds are highly variable (8). To prolong the
shelf-life of fresh fruits and vegetables, the growth of microbial
populations must be controlled, and hence several post-harvest
processes are employed to reduce initial high counts (9).
The food industry has been reducing the use of chemi-
cal preservatives due to increasing pressure from consumers
to either completely remove them or to adopt more natural
alternatives for the extension the shelf life of foods (10). To
reduce health hazards and economic losses due to foodborne
microorganisms, particular interest has been focused on the
potential application of essential oils, spices and herbs that have
been shown to possess antimicrobial activities (11). Most stud-
ies have been conducted using oils in vitro on microbiological
media (12–14); consequently, little is understood about their
effectiveness when applied to food. The use of oils, however,
may be limited due to their flavor, since effective antimicrobial
doses may exceed acceptable levels from an organoleptical
point of view (9). Their antimicrobial action depends on the
type, composition and concentration of the oils, type and
concentration of the target microorganism, composition of
the substrate, processing and storage conditions (14,15).
Moreover, to improve the shelf-life of the packaged food, an
active packaging material could be created by adding an oil as
an active compound to the wax formulation before coating of
the pack material (16).
The present work studied the application of three oils as
natural preservatives against some pathogens on fresh foods
like grated carrots.
Poiana et al.