Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 27 (3) (2013) 783~792
www.springerlink.com/content/1738-494x
DOI 10.1007/s12206-013-0124-9
The effect of anisotropy on wrinkling of tube under rotary draw bending
†
Kourosh Hasanpour
1,*
, Mahmoud Barati
2
, Behnaz Amini
3
and Mehrdad Poursina
1
1
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Isfahan, P.O.Box 81746-73441, Isfahan, Iran
2
Department of Applied Mechanics, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, K.N. Toosi University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
3
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Islamic Azad University, Khomeinishahr Branch, Iran
(Manuscript Received February 9, 2012; Revised August 4, 2012; Accepted October 3, 2012)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract
Rotary draw tube bending is one of the most complex tube forming processes subject to different process parameters such as material
properties and geometry. This process is being practiced in more and more applications in industry due to its high efficiency, high form-
ing precision and quality. However, improper process parameters can lead to wrinkling which restrict the thin walled tube bending.
Therefore, the prediction and prevention of wrinkling is very important. Despite its importance, the effect of anisotropy on the occurrence
of wrinkling was not considered in the literature up to now. In this investigation, a quantitative study on the wrinkling of thin walled tube
bending is carried out through a finite element model of the process using velocity integral parameter, which is used for the detection of
wrinkles. The other methods usually warn the wrinkling initiation with no precise location prediction. In addition, the effects of some
process parameters, specially normal and planar anisotropy on the tube wrinkling are investigated. It is shown that increasing normal and
planar anisotropy (increasing r
0
and r
90
values) result in a decrease in tube wrinkling.
Keywords: Normal anisotropy; Planar anisotropy; Rotary draw bending; Velocity integral parameter; Wrinkling
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Introduction
Thin-walled tubes have been widely used in different indus-
tries such as aerospace, automobile and air conditioning indus-
tries. The rotary draw bending of the thin walled tubes is
broadly applied due to its high forming quality and meeting
the requirement of increasing needs for high strength per
weight ratio products. However, the inner side of thin walled
tubes may experience wrinkling if inappropriate process pa-
rameters are employed, especially for tubes with large diame-
ter and thin wall thickness. Rapid and accurate prediction of
wrinkling phenomenon is one of the key problems that have to
be urgently solved for the development of this process. Many
researchers have simulated the rotary draw tube bending proc-
ess to study the effect of different parameters on the tube
wrinkling. Li et al. developed a complete 3D elastic-plastic
finite element (FE) model of the process using
ABAQUS/explicit code. They analyzed the forming character-
istics by analytical and experimental methods. In their paper,
the plastic deformation characteristics with small bending
radius and interactive effects of push assistant loading condi-
tions on wall thinning were investigated [1-6]. Kumar simu-
lated rotary draw tube bending to find the optimum process
parameters that prevent wrinkle effects, and then studied vari-
ous process parameters such as different dies position and
tube/different dies interactions [7]. Zhang et al. proposed a
modification on the adaptive dynamic relaxation method
which improves the efficiency in solving non-linear problems.
Then, they analyzed the elastic-plastic bending of circular
plates in large deflections and their subsequent wrinkling.
Their study led to satisfactory results compared with corre-
sponding experimental ones [8]. Yang et al. established a 3D
elastic-plastic finite element model and a wrinkling energy
prediction model under multi-die constraints considering the
characteristics of the bending processes of thin-walled tubes of
aluminum with large diameters [9]. Li et al. developed an
energy-based wrinkling prediction model for thin walled tube
bending by applying the energy principle, combined with
analytical and FE based numerical methods [10]. Orban et al.
developed a finite element model to simulate rotary draw tube
bending and applied the local variation of normal-to-surface
velocity for wrinkling detection, and then provided a basis for
developing an adaptive loading scheme to optimize end boost-
ing without inducing wrinkles in the bent tube [11]. They ap-
plied the velocity integral parameter which is the time integra-
tion of the second-order normal velocity difference and is
mathematically related to the curvature change along the tube
wall. This parameter was developed in order to detect onset of
wrinkling in the simulations. It was verified that a rapid in-
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +98 3117934021, Fax.: +98 3117932746
E-mail address: hasanpour@eng.ui.ac.ir
†
Recommended by Associate Editor Kyeongsik Woo
© KSME & Springer 2013