Identifying Governance Dimensions to Evaluate
Information Systems Security in Organizations
Gurpreet Dhillon
1
, Gurvirender Tejay
2
, and Weiyin Hong
3
Virginia Commonwealth University
1, 2
; University of Nevada, Las Vegas
3
gdhillon@vcu.edu
1
, tejaygp@vcu.edu
2
, whong@unlv.nevada.edu
3
Abstract
Prior studies in information systems security have a
limited emphasis on empirically identifying security
dimensions. This research paper presents the results of
an empirical study to understand governance
dimensions of information systems security. The
research study was conducted in three phases
involving interviews, an exploratory phase and a
confirmatory phase. The exploratory phase generated
a 4-factor, 16-item model for behavioral security of an
organization. The confirmatory phase involving
structural equation modeling validated the impact of
governance dimensions on the overall information
systems security of an organization. Data was
collected from two different samples of 163 and 175
respondents for each phase respectively. The results
suggest that the governance dimensions impact
information system security of an organization through
behavioral security.
1. Introduction
In today’s interconnected world organizations are
increasingly becoming dependent on information
systems. The security risks to information systems
have also steadily increased. Organizational members
become extremely important in the role as frontline
defense of an organization. We have seen way too
often employees fall prey to social engineering ploys
of hackers. This is but only one aspect of the problem.
Any type of control would ultimately be implemented
by an individual. As such, it becomes pertinent to
understand the behavior of people in an organization
as it would assist in propagating an information
security consciousness [1].
In spite of increased incidents of information
system security breaches and the ever-increasing
reliance of organizations on information technologies,
there is limited understanding of various dimensions
that result in information systems security problems
[2]. There is very little empirical research that has
investigated various aspects of information systems
security, in particular the nature and scope of its
dimensions. There is also a limited understanding of
how organizations manage the various information
systems security dimensions and what potential
problems there might be [3]. As a consequence there is
a clear need to identify and establish mechanisms that
would be required to successfully manage information
systems security.
In this study, we address these important concerns
and evaluate the related information systems security
issues. The overall objective of this research is to
investigate various behavioral dimensions of
information systems security. The argument of the
research paper is that the knowledge of information
systems security dimensions would allow
organizations to expend effort in an efficient and
effective manner, subsequently leading to a secure
organization. It is imperative to develop methods that
would allow some manner of assessment of security in
an organizational context.
2. Theoretical development
Concerns for security are not new [4]. Given our
increased reliance on information technologies,
worries about security breaches have compounded [5].
Information systems security literature has emphasized
the importance of “softer” behavioral issues associated
with people in ensuring security in an organization. As
[2] argue, there is too much emphasis on technological
solutions as compared to that on people in addressing
the issues of information systems security. A body of
literature in the field of information systems security
has highlighted the criticality of establishing
responsibility structures for the success of information
systems security management ([6], [7]). Responsibility
Proceedings of the 40th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences - 2007
1 © 1530-1605/07 $20.00 2007 IEEE
Proceedings of the 40th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS'07)
0-7695-2755-8/07 $20.00 © 2007