Child and adolescent psychiatric
disorders predicting adult personality
disorder: A follow-up study
MIA RAMKLINT, ANNE-LIIS VON KNORRING, LARS VON KNORRING*, LISA
EKSELIUS
Ramklint M, von Knorring A-L, von Knorring L, Ekselius L. Child and adolescent psychi-
atric disorders predicting adult personality disorder: A follow-up study. Nord J Psychiatry
2003;57:23 – 28. Oslo. ISSN 0803-9488.
The objective of this study was to examine associations between childhood and adolescent
psychiatric disorders and adult personality disorders in a group of former child psychiatric
inpatients. One hundred and fifty-eight former inpatients with a mean age of 30.5 7.1 years
at investigation had their childhood and adolescent Axis I disorders, obtained from their
medical records, coded into DSM-IV diagnoses. Personality disorders in adulthood were
assessed by means of the DSM-IV and ICD-10 Personality Questionnaire (DIP-Q). The
predictive effects of child and adolescent Axis I disorders on adult personality disorders were
examined with logistic regression analyses. The odds of adult schizoid, avoidant, dependent,
borderline and schizotypal personality disorders increased by almost 10, five, four, three and
three times, respectively, given a prior major depressive disorder. Those effects were indepen-
dent of age, sex and other Axis I disorders. In addition, the odds of adult narcissistic and
antisocial personality disorders increased by more than six and five times, respectively, given
a prior disruptive disorder, and the odds of adult borderline, schizotypal, avoidant and
paranoid personality disorders increased between two and three times given a prior sub-
stance-related disorder. The results illustrate an association between mental disorders in
childhood and adolescence and adult personality disorders. Identification and successful
treatment of childhood psychiatric disorders may help to reduce the risk for subsequent
development of an adult personality disorder.
• Child and adolescent psychopathology, DIP -Q, Follow -up studies, Mental disorders, Personal -
ity disorders.
Mia Ramklint, M.D., Ph.D., Department of Neuroscience, Psychiatry, University Hospital,
SE-751 85 Uppsala, Sweden. E-mail: mia.ramklint@bupinst.uu.se; Accepted: 9 December 2001.
I
ndividuals afflicted with childhood and adolescent
mental disorders have an increased risk for poor
outcome in adulthood (1 – 4). Thus, mental disorders
are much more common in adults who have been
treated for such disorders in childhood or adolescence
(5, 6). In a 22–25-year follow-up study of former child
psychiatric inpatients, Thomsen (1) found that approxi-
mately one-third of the sample had at least one read-
mission after the age of 18 years. There are also
significantly higher rates of delinquency, disability and
mortality in former adolescent psychiatric inpatients
followed up 15 – 33 years after hospitalization as com-
pared to those for the general population (3).
Previous investigations suggest that there is a sub-
stantial association between childhood and adolescent
onset of mental disorders and adult personality disor-
ders (7 – 9). Specifically, there is an association between
childhood disruptive behaviours and personality disor-
ders in all clusters, particularly between conduct disor-
der and adult antisocial personality disorder (7, 9 – 13).
Such an association has also been shown between child
and adolescent mood disorders on the one hand, and
the emotional dramatic (cluster B) and anxious fearful
(cluster C) personality disorders on the other (7), as
well as dependent, antisocial, passive – aggressive and
histrionic personality disorders (14). There is also an
association between anxiety disorders and the anxious
fearful (cluster C) and odd eccentric (cluster A) person-
ality disorders (7, 8). Finally, there is a very strong link
between substance-related disorders and personality
disorders, particularly in cluster B (15).
Although these studies have linked child and adoles-
cent psychopathology to the development of adult per-
* Declaration of interest: The author is Editor-in-Chief of the Nordic
Journal of Psychiatry.
© 2003 Taylor & Francis 23
Nord J Psychiatry Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Uppsala Universitetsbibliotek on 08/14/13
For personal use only.