Book Review 1
Book Review
Review of Whose Game? Gender and Power
in Fantasy Sports
By Rebecca Joyce Kissane and Sarah Winslow
Temple University Press 2020, 242 pages. ISBN: 9781439918876.
http://tupress.temple.edu/book/20000000009748
Reviewer: Tristan Bridges, University of California, Santa Barbara, USA
I
knew little about fantasy sports leagues before reading Kissane and
Winslow’s multi-method analysis of participants in fantasy sports. In Whose
Game? Gender and Power in Fantasy Sports, Kissane and Winslow examine
the ways that gender, race, and class shape the structure and experience of
fantasy sports participation in ways that reproduce an intersectional array of
inequalities under the guise of “good fun.” Their central argument is that fantasy
sports matter and are more than an insignificant pastime. They show how diverse
forms of identity and inequality are policed and maintained in ways that allow
women to participate, but work to (re) situate them as outsiders within the world
of fantasy sports.
One of the elements of the book that I enjoyed a great deal is that it is a
sociological study of something I think many assume to be mundane, focusing
on everyday participants in a pastime that is much larger than I had realized—
estimates of the industry are upwards of $7 billion annually (p. 5). Kissane and
Winslow document the ways that gender, race, and class inequality are deeply
embedded in the interactions that structure fantasy sports leagues. And as with
many other social contexts, men with concentrated collections of privileged
identities not only dominate the social context of fantasy sports, but also do
so in ways that simultaneously reflect and reinforce enduring and intersectional
forms of power and systems of inequality.
Fantasy sports offer new more interactive versions of being a fan, one that
offers people participating in fantasy sports more of a feeling of shared accom-
plishment with athletes, fostering new ways of feeling closer to the action. Indeed,
fantasy sports have quite literally altered the landscape of sports consumption
and fandom. The context enables fans to feel control and ownership not offered
in the same ways by what Kissane and Winslow refer to as “traditional fandom.”
While traditional fandom involves and rewards authentic allegiance to a specific
team or teams, fantasy sports fandom extends and transforms this through
© The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. All rights reserved. For permissions,
please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com.
Social Forces 1–3
doi:10.1093/sf/soaa138
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/sf/advance-article/doi/10.1093/sf/soaa138/6056298 by Columbia University, tbridges@soc.ucsb.edu on 08 January 2021