2021 IEEE PES/IAS PowerAfrica
978-1-6654-0311-5/21/$31.00 ©2021 IEEE
The Impact of Wind Generation on Low
Frequency Oscillation in Power Systems
Mohammad M. Almomani
Elec. Engineering Department
Mutah University
Karak, Jordan
monqedmohammad@gmail.com
Abdullah Odienat
Elec. Engineering Department
Al-Ahliya Amman University
Amman,Jordan
a.odienat@ammanu.edu.jo
Seba F. Al-Gharaibeh
Elec. Engineering Department
Mutah University
Karak, Jordan
620180441015@mutah.edu.jo
Khaled Alawasa
Elec. Engineering Department
Mutah University
Karak, Jordan
Kmalawasa@gmail.com
Abstract—Integration the renewable energy resources (RES)
with the modern power system is increased in the last decays
due to its environmental and economic benefits. In contrast
these technologies impact on the dynamic behavior of the power
system. In this paper, the effect of wind turbine penetration
level on the low frequency oscillations is investigated. Both local
and interarea oscillation modes are covered in the study. Two
types of wind turbine are selected here; fixed speed wind
turbine (FSWT) and double-fed induction generator (DFIG).
The impact of the existence of the FSWT and the penetration
level of the DFIG on the electromechanical oscillations are
conducted. The results show that the penetration level of the
wind turbine is highly impact on the low frequency oscillations.
Some local modes are highly affected by these types of
generation.
Index Terms—RES, Fixed speed wind turbine, DFIG, LFO,
WAMPAC, PMU, local area oscillation, interarea oscillation.
I. INTRODUCTION
Any power system has two networks: a power flow
network and a data flow network. In the traditional power
system, the power flow and data flow networks have only one
direction, so the power is transmitted from the huge
generation area via a high voltage transmission system to
multi-distribution areas, and the data is transmitted from the
loads (customers) to the control center (server). When the
smart grid takes a position in the power grid, these networks
are dramatically changed.
The smart grids have multi-type of the generation with
multi-size at different locations (in generation and
distribution areas [1]); also, they introduce new concepts
(new devices and algorithms) for the monitoring, control, and
protection systems; therefore, WAMS based on PMUs is
presented for real-time monitoring, control and protection
systems (WAMPAC) for the transmission level (mainly) [2].
The power and data networks in a smart grid are bi-
directional transferred due to distribution generators and
WAMPAC. Using the WAMPAC, the real-time data is
collected by PMUs and transmitted via communication
channels to the control center (real-time monitoring), then to
the high-level energy management systems include real-time
optimal power flow, contingency analysis, real-time
economic dispatch and other real-time applications to
identify the optimal situation to the system. After that, the
feedback signals are sent from the control center to the
actuators (wide-area control systems), relays (wide-area
protection [3-4]) and generators (automatic generation
control). These technologies can help to increase the safe
penetration level of the renewable energy in the system. Once
the renewable energy penetration level exceeds the safe limit,
the inertia of the system decreases to a dangerous level. To
make a clear view on the impact of these energy on the system
dynamic performance, each type of generation has to be
considered alone. For example, the modelling of the PV [5]
may mainly impact on the inertia of the system.
In this research, model-based small-signal (Eigen value
analysis) analyzer for the low-frequency oscillations is
generated for a three-area test system. The selected test
system has three local area modes (one for each area) and two
interarea modes. Thenceforward, two types of wind
generations are added to the three-area test system to study
their effect on the eigenvalue analyses; fixed speed wind
turbine (FSWT) and double fed induction generator (DFIG).
These generators cover types 1 and 3 of the wind generation
types, whereas the dynamic response of type 2 is similar to
the dynamic response of type 1 and type 4 wind turbine is
handled in [6]. The two wind generators are added to different
system topologies and operation point to show the relation
between the penetration level and the system topology and
operation points.
In the next section in this paper, section II, the model of
synchronous generators and wind turbines for low frequency
oscillation application are discussed. The impacts of FSWT
on the low frequency oscillation are presented in section IV,
then, the results of adding DFIG to the three-area test system
is shown in section V.
II. SYSTM UNDER STUDY
A. System Modeling
Three-area test system [7] is used here to present the
impact of the wind turbine on the low frequency oscillation.
This test system has three similar areas with two synchronous
generators and a load in each area. To show the impact of
wind generation on the interarea oscillation modes for strong
and weak tie-lines connection, two configurations are
considered; string configuration and ring configuration.
Where the three areas are connected in the string
configuration stronger than that in ring configuration. The
single line diagrams of these configurations are shown in
Figures 1-2. On the other hand, three different operation
points are considered. In each operation point, there is one
area heavy loaded and one area lightly loaded, where the first
area is heavy loaded in the first operation point and lightly
loaded in the second operation point, the second area is heavy
loaded in second operation point and lightly loaded in the
third and the third area is heavy loaded in the third operation
point and lightly loaded in the first. In each case, 400MW is
transmitted from lightly loaded area to heavy loaded area.
These operation points are applied to the two configurations;