1379
Prediction of pressure fluctuations on sloping
stilling basins
A. Güven, M. Günal, and A. Çevik
Abstract: Various types of hydraulic jump occurring on horizontal and sloping channels have been analyzed experimen-
tally, theoretically, and numerically and the results are available in the literature. In this study, artificial neural network
models were developed to simulate the mean pressure fluctuations beneath a hydraulic jump occurring on sloping stilling
basins. Multilayers feed a forward neural network with a back-propagation learning algorithm to model the pressure fluc-
tuations beneath such a type of hydraulic jump (B-jump). An explicit formula that predicts the mean pressure fluctuation
in terms of the characteristics that contribute most to the hydraulic jump occurring on the sloping basins is presented. The
proposed neural network models are compared with linear and nonlinear regression models that were developed using
considered physical parameters. The results of the neural network modelling are found to be superior to the regression
models and are in good agreement with the experimental results due to relatively small values of error (mean absolute
percentage error).
Key words: neural networks, pressure fluctuation, hydraulic jump, sloping stilling basin, explicit NN formulation,
regression analysis.
Résumé : Divers types de ressauts hydrauliques se trouvant dans les canaux horizontaux et inclinés ont été analysés
expérimentalement, théoriquement et numériquement et les résultats sont disponibles dans la littérature. La présente
étude développe des modèles de réseaux neuronaux artificiels pour simuler les variations moyennes de pression sous
les ressauts hydrauliques le long des bassins d’amortissement inclinés. Un réseau neuronal à couches non bouclé muni
d’un algorithme d’apprentissage à rétropropagation est utilisé pour modéliser les variations de pression sous de tels types
de ressauts hydrauliques (B-Jump). Une formule explicite qui prédit la variation moyenne de pression en termes des
caractéristiques contribuant le plus au ressaut hydraulique dans les bassins d’amortissement est présentée. Les modèles
de réseaux neuronaux artificiels proposés sont comparés aux modèles de régression linéaire et non linéaire développés en
utilisant les paramètres physiques arrêtés. Les résultats de la modélisation des réseaux neuronaux s’avèrent supérieurs à
ceux des modèles de régression et présentent une bonne corrélation avec les résultats expérimentaux en raison des valeurs
relativement petites de l’erreur (pourcentage d’erreur moyenne absolue).
Mots clés : réseaux neuronaux, variation de pression, ressaut hydraulique, bassin d’amortissement incliné, formulation de
réseau neuronal explicite, analyse de régression.
[Traduit par la Rédaction]
Introduction
Over the years, several aspects of hydraulic jumps forming
in horizontal and sloping channels have been investigated. In an
open channel, if the downstream depth is greater than the down-
stream sequent depth, the jump moves upstream to submerge
the incoming flow. Such a jump is called a submerged hydraulic
jump. The hydraulic jump forming in the stilling basin is a free
hydraulic jump if it forms at the foot of the spillway. Usually,
the jump is enclosed within a stilling basin. On the other hand, if
the downstream depth of the flow in the stilling basin is greater
than the sequent depth, the hydraulic jump moves towards the
Received 1 May 2006. Revision accepted 19 July 2006. Published
on the NRC Research Press Web site at http://cjce.nrc.ca/ on 23
January 2007.
A. Güven,
1
M. Günal, and A. Çevik. Department of Civil Engi-
neering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Gaziantep, 27310
Gaziantep, Turkey.
Written discussion of this article is welcomed and will be received
by the Editor until 31 March 2007.
1
Corresponding author (e-mail: aguven@gantep.edu.tr).
spillway with its toe positioned on the spillway. Such a jump
is called a B-jump and a B-jump may be considered to belong
to the class of submerged jumps with the entering flow at an
angle to the bed of the channel (Fig. 1). Mean flow character-
istics of a B-jump were investigated in detail by Hager (1989),
and Ohtsu and Yasuda (1990, 1991). These studies relate to the
mean velocity measurements, roller length, and length of the
jump.
Abdul Khader and Elongo (1974), Lopardo and Henning
(1985), Toso and Bowers (1988), and Fattor et al. (2001) stud-
ied statistical properties of fluctuating pressures beneath a hy-
draulic jump formed downstream of the spillway. On the other
hand,Vasiliev and Bukreyev (1967), Narasimhan and Bhargava
(1976), Narayanan (1978), and Lopardo et al. (2004) measured
the intensity of the fluctuating pressures beneath submerged
and free jumps downstream of a sluice gate in the horizontal
channel. Clearly, these two sets of experiments with respect to
hydraulic jumps, one downstream of a spillway and the other
downstream of a sluice gate, are different with respect to the up-
stream conditions. It is well known that different upstream con-
ditions such as the mean velocity distribution and intensity of
turbulence have a strong influence on the magnitude of the pres-
sure fluctuations and mean flow properties. It is worth noting
Can. J. Civ. Eng. 33: 1379–1388 (2006) doi: 10.1139/L06-101 © 2006 NRC Canada