Security and Collaborative Groupware Tools in Education
A Case Study at the University of Bahrain
Resala AlAdraj
PhD candidate
Department of Computer Science, University of Warwick
Coventry, UK
r.aladraj@warwick.ac.uk
Mike Joy
Associate Professor
Department of Computer Science, University of Warwick
Coventry, UK
m.s.joy@warwick.ac.uk
Abstract — This paper presents an evaluation of the security,
safety, and privacy of selected Online Collaborative
Groupware (OCG) tools such as Skype, Facebook, Wikis
and Gmail (SWFG) used to support learning activities from
the perception of the students, and with a particular focus on
the impact of their usage on student trust. A case study was
conducted with two groups of undergraduate students at the
University of Bahrain to identify and develop an efficient
model for using SWFG tools securely within learning. In
doing so, questionnaires were distributed post case study
among two different students groups A and B. The overall
finding of this study is that there are differences between
two groups in their usage with respect to security, privacy,
and trust for SWFG tools.
I. INTRODUCTION
During the last decade, the web has changed from a simple
hypertextual repository of documents to a powerful
communication medium. This change has caused
educational activities to be highly supported by web
applications which often include collaborative sessions. A
wide range of technologies has been prepared by
educational institutions in order to support collaboration
between learners and between learners and teachers. In
recent years, web-based technologies have allowed people
who are located in different places to interact with each
other in synchronous and asynchronous ways, which can
then support good collaborative learning activities.
Collaborative groupware can broadly be defined as a
process of learning in which two or more people learn
something together.
Discovery of the right tools to support groupware, and
intensive use of technology which supports social activities
such as chatting and messaging, should support student
learning and hence ensure a successful educational outcome.
The ubiquity of the Internet and online technologies
provides a framework within which Online Collaborative
Groupware (OCG) tools become widely available and
provide benefits for student learning. However, there are
challenges facing OCG tools, and student concerns about
their usage, for example security. Hence, the researcher has
chosen Skype, Facebook, Wikis and Gmail (SWFG) as a an
example of the OCG tools to evaluate the security, safety,
trust and privacy from the perceptions of the students .In
doing so, a case study was conducted at the University of
Bahrain (UOB) with two groups of undergraduate students
A and B. Group A used SWFG without applying security
mechanisms and group B used SWFG with security
mechanisms.
Hence, the aim of this paper is to answer the following
research questions.
1) Do SWFG tools used by group B have higher
levels of security when compared to the use of
these tools by group A?
2) Do SWFG tools used by group B have higher
levels of trust when compared to the use of these
tools by group A?
3) Do SWFG tools used by group B have higher
levels of privacy when compared to the use of
these tools by group A?
4) Do SWFG tools used by group B have higher
levels of safety when compared to the use of these
tools by group A?
In order to answer the research questions four hypotheses
were formulated related to the groups A and B in the cases
of security, safety, privacy, and trust. The hypotheses are as
follows.
A. Hypothesis 1
Ho: SWFG tools used by group B post- experiment do not
give a higher level of security when compared to the use of
these tools by group A post- experiment.
Ha: SWFG tools used by group B post- experiment give a
higher level of security when compared to the use of these
tools by group A post- experiment.
B. Hypothesis 2
2013 Fourth International Conference on e-Learning Best Practices in Management, Design and Development of
e-Courses: Standards of Excellence and Creativity
978-0-7695-5036-7/13 $26.00 © 2013 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/ECONF.2013.47
421
2013 Fourth International Conference on e-Learning "Best Practices in Management, Design and Development of
e-Courses: Standards of Excellence and Creativity"
978-0-7695-5036-7/13 $26.00 © 2013 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/ECONF.2013.56
421