Research Article
Ontology-Based Analysis of Manufacturing Processes: Lessons
LearnedfromtheCaseStudyofWireHarnessProduction
L´ aszl´ oNagy,Tam´ as Ruppert ,andJ´ anos Abonyi
MTA-PE Lend¨ ulet Complex Systems Monitoring Research Group, Department of Process Engineering, University of Pannonia,
Egyetem u. 10, POB 158, Veszpr´ em H-8200, Hungary
CorrespondenceshouldbeaddressedtoTam´ asRuppert;ruppert@abonyilab.com
Received 7 June 2021; Revised 13 October 2021; Accepted 25 October 2021; Published 19 November 2021
AcademicEditor:MuhammadJavaid
Copyright©2021L´ aszl´ oNagyetal.isisanopenaccessarticledistributedundertheCreativeCommonsAttributionLicense,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Effective information management is critical for the development of manufacturing processes. is paper aims to provide an
overviewofontologiesthatcanbeutilizedinbuildingIndustry4.0applications.emaincontributionsoftheworkarethatit
highlights ontologies that are suitable for manufacturing management and recommends the multilayer-network-based inter-
pretation and analysis of ontology-based databases. is article not only serves as a reference for engineers and researchers on
ontologies but also presents a reproducible industrial case study that describes the ontology-based model of a wire harness
assembly manufacturing process.
1.Introduction
Managinginformationanddatafromproductionsystemsis
critical for digital transformation, especially in Industry 4.0
applications,wherethehorizontalandverticalintegrationof
systemsrequiresmoreefficientdataprocessing.Moreefforts
havebeenmadetostandardizethisarea,suchastheANSI/
ISA-95 international standard or RAMI 4.0 (Reference
Architectural Model Industrie 4.0) [1]. Furthermore, there
are ongoing studies in the field of different methodologies
and data structurization that aim to support production-
related decision-making processes [2] or create models
without simulation software-specific knowledge [3]. For a
similar purpose, process mining solutions were also devel-
oped to discover, analyze, and improve business processes
based on event logs of information systems [4, 5].
Semantic data-based modelling structures the data in a
specific logical way [6]. Ontology models also contain se-
mantic information to provide a basic meaning of the data
and describe their internal relationships [7]. Knowledge
graph models provide a framework for data integration,
processing, analytics, and sharing as a collection of inter-
linked descriptions of entities—objects, events, or concepts
[8, 9].
Figure 1 shows the emerging trend of research papers
related to ontologies. As can be seen, the technology
appearedaround2002,andtherapidlyincreasingnumberof
publications in the topic knowledge graphs confirms its
success and wide applicability range.
Because of the importance of horizontal and vertical
integration in Industry 4.0, ontologies are being used in
production systems to share information over an increas-
ingly wide range [1]. Manufacturing companies are faced
with many information sharing tasks such as B2M, M2M,
and B2B (communication channels between business (B)
and/ormachine(M)units)[10,11].einformationhasto
be transferred between information systems, optimization
methods,ordigitaltwinsimulators[12].Duetothegrowing
demand,thepreviouslyproposeddevelopmentsforISA-95,
ISA-88, AutomationML (Automation Markup Language),
and B2MML (Business to Manufacturing Markup Lan-
guage) industry standards as well as frameworks have in-
tensified[1];moreover,thesearebasedonknowledgegraphs
or ontologies.
Duringthefourthindustrialrevolution,newmethods
emerged to deal with this problem, and it can be stated
that ontology modelling [13] and knowledge represen-
tation are part of the future trends [14], which can be
Hindawi
Complexity
Volume 2021, Article ID 8603515, 21 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/8603515