Cognitive Approach in Simulation and Control
Z. Avdeeva*, S. Kovriga*
* Institute of Control Sciences RAS, Moscow, Russia, 117997,
Profsoyuznaya 65, e-mail: max@ipu.ru
Abstract: Paper presents brief review of cognitive approach in simulation and control. A class of
control problems that are advisable to be solved via cognitive simulation is defined. The basic
definitions are made. The method for forming strategy of ill-structured problem solution on the base
of cognitive models as applies to socio-economic system is presented. Some trends of further
development of cognitive approach are denoted. Copyright ©2008 IFAC.
Keywords: cognitive map, decision making, ill-structured system
1. INTRODUCTION
The decision theory studying control problems for systems of
various nature (technical, biological, socio-economic) has
become independent science branch during last decades. The
decision theory actively uses methods of mathematics,
psychology, informatics. The cognitive simulation is one of
the new approaches of modern decision theory. This applies
for studying control of ill-structured systems and situations
(Narayanan and Armstrong [2005], Chaib-draa [2002], Kim
[2000], Huff [1990], Kosko [1986], Sawaragi et al [1986],
Heradstvein and Narvesen [1978], Axelrod [1976], Roberts
[1976]) that is developed in several scientific subdivisions of
Trapeznikov Institute of Control Sciences RAS (Avdeeva et
al. [2007], Avdeeva [2006], Avdeeva et al. [2003], Kuznetsov
et al. [2006], Kulba et al. [2004], Maximov and
Kornoushenko [2001], Maximov [2001], Abramova et al.
[1999]). Talking about effective control methods for complex
systems, academician I.V. Prangishvili highlighted the
cognitive simulation for solving of ill-structured problems
that are frequently encountered in control of complex systems
among practically justified scientific methods for increasing
control effectiveness in organizational, socio-economic and
political systems (Prangishvili [2002], Abramova et al.
[1999]).
The main purpose of this paper is to form complete idea of
cognitive approach actively developing now in the control
science and interdisciplinary sciences (sociology, economy,
etc.), further specification of basic concepts of this approach
in control science, as well as defining a class of control
problems that are advisable to be solved by cognitive
simulation.
2. BRIEF HISTORY
OF COGNITIVE APPROACH EVOLUTION
Origins of concept “cognitive map” lie in psychology
(Tolman [1946]). Studying cognitive maps – subjective
representations of spatial organization of outer world – has
gained in fundamental importance in the framework of
studying features of human perception of his surroundings.
The cognitive map is the concept concerning cognitive
processes related to gathering, representation, and processing
of information on the environment during which an
individual is not only a passive observer, but actively
interacts with his environment. Forming cognitive maps by
an individual is understood as the process consisting of series
of psychological transformations. By means of these
transformations, an individual gathers, stores, copies, recalls
and manipulates information on relative locations and
attributes of his spatial surroundings. This process is essential
component of decision making for spatial behaviour. The
psychological research is directed to a greater extent toward
studying these very processes and their influence onto
forming certain representations allowing an individual to act
and make decisions in his environment.
In political science and sociology, the method of cognitive
simulation was developed in 1960–1980 in papers of
American researcher R. Axelrod and his colleagues from
USA and Scandinavia (Heradstvein and Narvesen [1978],
Axelrod [1976]).
It should be noted that many authors also use the term
“cognitive mapping”. In any case, research of problem
situation is based on model construction on the base of a
cognitive map. The differences consist only in applied
modifications of cognitive maps and methods of their formal
processing.
In political science and sociology, “cognitive map” is not
related to spatial orientation. It is interpreted as an
individual’s schematic representation of world image
fragment relating to concrete problem situation. In this
context, cognitive map is the way for representing thought
structures directed toward a concrete problem and allowing to
simulate politician’s mentation during deliberation of action
stimulating identification of further events (Heradstvein and
Narvesen [1978]).
Construction and analysis of cognitive maps allow revealing
causal structure of reasoning presented in political texts and,
Proceedings of the 17th World Congress
The International Federation of Automatic Control
Seoul, Korea, July 6-11, 2008
978-1-1234-7890-2/08/$20.00 © 2008 IFAC 1613 10.3182/20080706-5-KR-1001.3530