Hindawi Publishing Corporation
International Journal of Microwave Science and Technology
Volume 2008, Article ID 784526, 7 pages
doi:10.1155/2008/784526
Research Article
A New Design of Compact 4 × 4 Butler Matrix for
ISM Applications
Mbarek Traii,
1
Mourad Nedil,
2
Ali Gharsallah,
1
and Tayeb A. Denidni
3
1
Laboratory of Electronic, Faculty of Sciences of Tunis, Tunis El Manar University, 2092 Tunis, Tunisia
2
Laboratoire de Recherche T´ el´ ebec en Communications Souterraines LRTCS 450, 3e Avenue,
Local 103 Val-d’Or (Qu´ ebec), Canada J9P 1S2
3
INRS-EMT, Universit´ e de Qu´ ebec, Place Bonaventure 800, de la Gauchti` ere Ouest West, Suite 6900,
Montr´ eal, QC, Canada H5A 1K6
Correspondence should be addressed to Mbarek Traii, traii moncef@yahoo.fr
Received 5 May 2008; Revised 9 September 2008; Accepted 22 December 2008
Recommended by Kenjiro Nishikawa
A novel design of a compact 4 × 4 Butler matrix is presented. All the design is based on the use of a Lange coupler with certain
geometrical characteristics. This matrix occupies only 20% of the size of the conventional Butler matrix at the same frequency (80%
of compactness). To examine the performance of the proposed matrix, the Lange coupler and the Butler matrix were simulated
using Momentum (ADS) and IE3D softwares. Simulation results of magnitude and phase show a good performance. Furthermore,
a four-antenna array was also designed at 2.45 GHz and then connected to the matrix to form a beamforming antenna system. As
a result, four orthogonal beams at −45
◦
, −15
◦
, 15
◦
, and 45
◦
are produced. This matrix is suitable for wireless application at ISM
band of 2.45 GHz.
Copyright © 2008 Mbarek Traii et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
1. Introduction
Smart antenna systems have been introduced to improve
wireless performance and to increase system capacity by
spatial filtering, which can separate spectrally and temporally
overlapping signals from multiple users. Switched beam
systems are referred as antenna-array systems that form
multiple-fixed beams with enhanced sensitivity in a specific
area. This antenna system detects signal strength, selects one
of the several predetermined fixed beams, and switches from
one beam to another as the user moves. One of the most
widely known of switched beam networks is Butler matrix
[1]. It is an N ×N passive feedingnetwork with beam steering
capabilities for phased array antennas with N outputs and N
inputs. Feeding an N-element antenna array using an N × N
Butler matrix, N orthogonal beams can be generated, and
each beam has a gain of the whole array.
In most cases, circuits are designed using branch-line
directional couplers [2]. However, in single-layer Butler
matrix, hybrid coupler takes up over 50% of the area. It has
a dimension of a quarter wavelength square and occupies
a significant amount of the board area. For reducing the
area, some techniques such as the use of lumped-element
[3] have been proposed. However, lumped inductors and
capacitors with the required values are not always available
and their tolerance is quite larger. Thus, the need for compact
circuits with simple structure and low cost is more and more
attractive.
The problem of miniaturization was reported in [4],
where semilumped branch-line couplers have been pro-
posed. The broadband 3 dB coupled line directional couplers
were used in [5]. In this case, a small size has been
achieved but the bandwidth of the Butler matrix is limited
by differential phase characteristics. In [6], the authors
have proposed a stripline Butler with broadband differential
phase matrix. However, the stripline technique presents high
manufacturing costs and complexity [7]. The most attractive
technique for designing and manufacturing microwave cir-
cuits is a microstrip technique since it uses a single laminate
layer and allows easy mounting of surface mount devices and
components.