Journal Name
Cite this: DOI: 10.1039/c0xx00000x
www.rsc.org/xxxxxx
Dynamic Article Links ►
ARTICLE TYPE
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry [year] [journal], [year], [vol], 00–00 | 1
Aqueous solutions of facial amphiphilic carbohydrates as sustainable
media for organocatalyzed direct aldol reactions
Ana Bellomo,
a,b
Richard Daniellou,
a,b,£,
* and Daniel Plusquellec
a,b
*
Received (in XXX, XXX) Xth XXXXXXXXX 20XX, Accepted Xth XXXXXXXXX 20XX
DOI: 10.1039/b000000x 5
The organocatalyzed direct aldol reaction was efficiently
performed in aqueous solutions of facial amphiphilic
carbohydrates with high diastereoselectivity and yield. Such
sustainable media in addition with the use of 2% catalyst
loading pave the way for the development of original 10
ecofriendly procedures through non-covalent induction.
Introduction
The aldol reaction is one of the most powerful methods of
forming carbon-carbon bonds and has tremendous synthetic
applications.
1
Biological systems have perfected this 15
stereospecific transformation by using enzymes: type I aldolases
function via the formation of an enamine intermediate with a
lysine residue whereas type II aldolases activate substrates by
forming a zinc enolate. Despite their lack of large-scale
compatibility and their narrow substrate specificity, aldolases 20
represent a great source of inspiration for the development of
catalysts. For example, catalytic antibodies have already
demonstrated to be useful tools in organic chemistry.
2
Seminal
works of List, Lerner and Barbas have also proved that small
molecules like L-proline are able to act as enamine-based aldol 25
catalysts whose simplicity contrast with the complex machinery
of enzymes.
3
However, even if these asymmetric reactions are
efficiently performed using both metal- and organocatalysts in
organic solvents, similar transformations in water generally
require the use of additives or co-solvents, or are just impossible 30
to perform.
4
As an alternative to the de novo design of water-compatible
catalysts,
5
we wish to develop environmentally friendly, efficient
and stereoselective protocols based on aqueous solutions of 35
sustainable natural products. Especially, inexpensive
carbohydrates like sucrose 1 or alkyl β-D-fructopyranosides 2
6
exhibiting facial amphiphilic characters, i.e. their pyranoside ring
displaying both a hydrophilic face and a hydrophobic region (Fig.
1), have already demonstrated their potency in selectively 40
promoting reductions, epoxidations and indium-promoted
allylations.
7
Faster reactions as well as better solubility of the
organic reactants were also observed. Thus, such original media
may constitute alternative solvents for the development of
sustainable chemistry. 45
Fig. 1 Structure and hydrophobic areas of facial amphiphilic
carbohydrates 1-2.
50
Herein we wish to report our findings concerning the mild and
stereoselective direct aldol reaction of cyclic ketones in aqueous
carbohydrate solutions. Small organic catalysts were selected
considering the formation of an enamine intermediate, resembling
the mechanistic pathway followed by L-proline and its 55
analogues.
8
Noteworthingly, as previous experiments have shown
the low potency of carbohydrates to orientate cyclic ketones in
water,
7c
we envisioned that sugars may still be involved in the
transition state, diminishing contacts with bulk water
9
and
allowing the orientation of the assumed enamine-incoming 60
aldehyde intermediate, thus influencing the stereochemical
outcome of the reaction.
Results and Discussion
The direct aldol reaction of cyclohexanone (5 equiv.) and m-
nitrobenzaldehyde (1 equiv.) in 1M aqueous solution of ethyl β- 65
D-fructopyranoside 2b was chosen as a model (Table 1). Initial
screenings were focused on the catalytic efficiency of
commercially available bases and their influence on the
diastereoselectivity. Furthermore, fixed catalyst loadings of 2 mol
% were used. As expected, L-proline was completely inefficient 70
for catalysing aldolisation in water (entry 1).
10
Ethanolamine, a
mimic of the lysine side chain, afforded compound 3 in nearly
90% yield (entries 2-3) but with long reaction times and expected
poor selectivities. The use of pyrrolidine as catalyst showed better
results (entries 4-5), enabling the completion of the reaction in 75
about 1 hour. For the first time, 2b was able to influence
significantly the syn/anti ratio increased to 1.9:1. L-Prolinol
(entries 6-7) exhibited low reactivity and similar 3:1
diastereoselectivities whether the sugar additive was present or
not. The existence of steric hindrance at position 2 of the 80