Thermal Management of Structured Adsorbents in CO
2
Capture
Processes
Fateme Rezaei* and Mattias Grahn
Division of Chemical Technology, Luleå University of Technology, SE-97187, Luleå , Sweden
ABSTRACT: In order to have an efficient adsorptive separation, structured adsorbents are expected to satisfy not only mass
transfer and pressure drop requirements but also thermal management requirements. To what extent the structure of adsorbent
affects the thermal behavior of the system is a question which will be addressed in this study. The primary purpose of this study
was to assess the performance of alternate adsorbents through development of numerical models for prediction of their thermal
behavior under a two-step pressure swing adsorption (PSA) condition. The single-step CO
2
breakthrough and temperature
profiles confirmed the efficiency of structured adsorbents in managing the thermal effects evolved in the bed under
nonisothermal conditions. Two-step PSA results also showed that under real cyclic processes, and especially during rapid cycling,
structured adsorbents maintain their superiority and introduce themselves as potential candidates for advanced PSA units.
However, the performance of a structured adsorbent is highly dependent on its dimensions and geometrical parameters
describing the structures, and these parameters should be optimized for each separation.
1. INTRODUCTION
Adsorption processes are commonly assumed to be isothermal.
This assumption is based on the fact that thermal effects caused
by heat generation inside the column impose negligible
influence on adsorption dynamics. However, in practice, this
assumption is no longer justified especially for high
concentration feeds in which the heat of adsorption generates
thermal waves in both axial and radial directions, affecting the
concentration profiles.
1-3
Therefore, in most cases, the rate of
adsorption may be controlled by both heat and mass transfer
kinetics, and hence, the nonisothermal nature of adsorptive gas
separation processes must be taken into account during process
design.
4-7
In our previous study,
8
we presented a new methodology to
find the optimal adsorbent structure and showed that for dilute
systems, parallel channel adsorbents in the form of laminate
structures exhibit substantially better performance than other
structures, but for the sake of computational simplicity we
confined our study to the case of isothermal operation only.
However, nonisothermal effects especially at higher feed
concentration are very important and can deteriorate process
efficiency and deform breakthrough curves. Therefore, in order
to have a comprehensive analysis of an adsorption process, it is
necessary to take into consideration an efficient thermal
management during cyclic adsorption processes such as
pressure swing adsorption (PSA) or temperature swing
adsorption (TSA).
Basically, there are two different approaches for managing
thermal effects in adsorptive gas separation processes, namely
external and internal management. In the first approach, the
thermal effect can be efficiently managed by employing an in-
bed multitubular heat exchanger to extract the heat of
adsorption from the column. To do so, the adsorbent material
is required to exhibit high effective thermal conductivity and a
high heat exchange coefficient. In this respect, the composite of
expanded natural graphite with activated carbon has been
already studied by several researchers.
9,10
This method is only
applicable to small scale columns and the difficulty associated
with its industrial application makes it impractical for real gas
separation units. In the internal mode of thermal management,
in order to control in situ thermal effects generated during
adsorption, the focus is given to adsorbent materials. In this
case, the goal is to employ the materials which are capable of
storing a large amount of heat and hence mitigating thermal
effects in such a way that isothermal conditions could be
maintained in the column. The materials used for this purpose
are normally phase change materials (PCMs) which can be
mixed with active adsorbent materials.
11
Sometimes different
adsorbent materials are blended to mitigate the heat generated
during adsorption. Under theses conditions the adsorption heat
is transferred from the “strong” adsorbent to the “weak”
adsorbent resulting in enhanced equilibrium capacity. This
method also possesses some limitations: the PCM could dilute
the amount of active adsorbent and reduce the adsorbent
loading on one hand and increase the characteristic diffusion
path and, hence, the mass transfer resistance on the other hand.
Another possible option to carefully manage the thermal
effects is to utilize adsorbent with different geometries than
pellets. The use of conventional adsorbent materials in the form
of beads or granules in advanced gas separation systems is
compromised when an efficient process with high performance
and low energy demand is required. Recently, various
structured adsorbents with enhanced adsorption characteristics
such as monolithic, laminates, and foam structures have gained
considerable attention as alternate candidates for traditional
adsorbent particles. Over the last 20 years, there have been
numerous patents on such systems including a theoretical
Received: May 17, 2011
Revised: October 3, 2011
Accepted: February 24, 2012
Published: February 24, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© 2012 American Chemical Society 4025 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ie201057p | Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2012, 51, 4025-4034