7th IEEE International Symposium on Applied (omputationallntelligence and Informatics· May 24-26, 2012 • Timi�oara, Romania
Searching for a nonlinear ODE model of vehicle
crash with genetic optimization
Andras Horvath*, Mikos F Hatwagner
t
, Istvan A. Harati
+
Szechenyi Istvan University, Gyor, Egyetem ter 1., H-9026, Hungary
*Depaent of Physics and Chemistry
t
Depaent of Information Technology
+
Department of Mathematics and Computational Science
Email: { horvatha.hatwagnf.harati } @sze.hu
Abstct-Vehicle crash is a very complex process, which can
be modelled in detils using the fnite element method (FEM),
but a simple, quasi-heuristic model with a limited number of
parameters is ofen more benefcial. In this paper we propose
a relatively simple dynamic model for deformation and force
during a frontal collision process, which has very similar behavior
to the experimental data. A genetic-type optimization of model
parameters is executed on thre car crash experimental data sets.
I. INTRODUCTION
The analysis of crash events plays a key role in several felds
of vehicle engineering practice. Some of the most important
are accident reconstruction, accident analysis, development
of active and passive vehicle safety systems, and in general
vehicle crashworthiness design [1], [2], [3]. A certain vehicle
crash event can be examined in many diferent points of view,
for example the before and after impact speed of the vehicles,
the movement of the damaged cars, the main characteristic of
the road, the amount and distribution of te absorbed energy,
deformation and deformation force during the collision [4],
[5]. From the above mentioned, in the feld of developing
passive vehicle safety the absorbed energy and the deforation
force are the most important quantities.
A detailed model of the highly nonlinear deformation pro
cesses is usually based on the fnite element method [6], [7],
[8]. This approach gives a complete description of te process,
but requires a detailed knowledge of geometry and material
properties, which are not known exactly in general, and as
a consequence of the huge number of degrees of freedom
te simulation requires extremely large computational power.
However, if we a contented with less detailed information
about the process, a simple model is more suitable [4], [9],
[10], [11], [12].
Altough we a looking for an 'as simple as possible'
dynamic model of deforation force, there are some natural
expectations for this quasi-heuristic model:
1) Limited number of model variables, e.g. 10-15, such
tat present computers can solve the system of equations
(diferential or algebraic) in fractions of a second and
complexity is tractable to the human mind.
2) Limited number of model parameters, e.g. 10-15.
3) Model parameters and equations should have physical
meaning. A completely theoretical multivariable func
tion approximation of measured data may be useful in
some situations, but it is better if the majority of the
model parameters and equations is in simple relation
with the real world, e.g. "efective spring constant".
4) The model should produce qualitively similar behavior
to the real system.
5) The parameters of the model can be identifed in a car
crash experiment and the model with the identifed pa
rameters should reproduce te experimental data witin
moderate (5-10%) relative eror.
There are a lot of very simple fnite dimension models in
the literature for vehicle crash events, for example the linear
force model, the bilinear force model [13], [14], the power law
force model [15], te elasto-plastic spring-mass model [16],
the viscoelastic model [17], or diferent stifess calculations
[18]. These models fulfll the expectations 1-3 above, but there
a signifcant phenomena that are not caught by them, e.g.
elastic recovery at the end of a process, or oscillations in force
time function. Harmati et. al. [19] proposed a more theoretical
approach, which is good at reproducing measured data and
uses a limited number of parameters but these parameters
of LPV (linear parameter varying) model have no physical
meaning, and the whole model is not based on physical laws,
and tus does not satisfy expectation 3.
In this paper we propose a model that fts all the re
quirements above. The proposed "sliding base point" model
is a six-variable ODE system with a physically meaningful
background with 7 parameters. We show that this system
produces the same qualitative behaviour as real experiments.
A genetic algorithm for parameter identifcation is presented
and applied to three experimental data sets. The results show
that the model with the identifed paeters can reproduce
measured force and deformation data witin 6-7% relative
error.
II. EXPERIMENTAL DATA
One of the many vehicle crash tests is the so called load
cell barier (LCB) test. The examined vehicle is driven into a
special barer which is equipped with force-sensors. During
the collision a well designed set of sensors in the back of
978-1-4673-1014-7/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE -131-