Abstract— In this paper, real-time feedback control of a nov-
el micro-machined 1-degree-of-freedom (1-DoF) thermal nano-
positioner with on-chip electrothermal positioning sensors is
presented. The actuation works based on thermal expansion of
silicon beams. The sensing mechanism works based on the dif-
ference between the electrical resistances of two electrically
biased identical Silicon beams. The difference increases with
displacement as the heat conductance of the sensor beams vary
oppositely with position, resulting in different beam tempera-
tures and resistances. The sensor pair is operated in a differen-
tial way to reduce low-frequency drift. The nanopositioner has
a nonlinear static input-output characteristic. An open-loop
control system is first designed using polynomials that approx-
imately compensate the nonlinear characteristics. It is experi-
mentally shown that plant uncertainties and sensor drift result
in unacceptable performance for open-loop control of the
thermal nanopositioner. Hence, feedback control methods are
necessary for accurate nanopositioning. A closed-loop feedback
control system was then designed using a proportional-integral
(PI) controller and the nonlinear compensator used for the
open-loop control system. The closed-loop system provides ac-
ceptable and robust tracking performance for a wide range of
set point values. For triangular reference tracking, which is
needed in raster-scanned SPM, the tracking performance of the
closed-loop system is further improved by incorporating a suit-
able pre-filter.
Index Terms-Thermal actuation, thermal position sensing, micro-
electromechanical system (MEMS), nanopositioning, feedback
control.
I. INTRODUCTION
igh precision nanopositioners have been used exten-
sively in many applications such as scanning probe
microscopy (SPM) [1], atomic force microscopy (AFM) [2],
and emerging ultrahigh density probe storage system [3, 4].
Although macro-scale nanopositioners can achieve nanome-
ter-scale positioning resolution and accuracy, they are rela-
tively large and expensive [5, 6]. Microelectromechanical
System (MEMS) nanopositioners have attracted increasing
research interest recently due to their small size, low cost,
Manuscript received September 28, 2010. This research was funded by
Australian Research Council (ARC) discovery grant- DP0774287.
Y.Zhu is with the School of Engineering, Griffith University, Australia
(email: y.zhu@griffith.edu.au).
A.Bazaei, S.O.R.Moheimani, and M.R.Yuce are with the School of Elec-
trical Engineering and Computer Science, the University of Newcastle,
Australia (email: {ali.bazaei, reza.moheimani, mehmet.yuce}
@newcastle.edu.au).
and highly parallel nanoscale manipulation and assembly
strategies [7]. Closed-loop feedback control of the position-
ers is highly desirable if a high degree of displacement pre-
cision is required, and such a control system needs an accu-
rate source of position information [8]. However, many of
the MEMS nanopositioners reported in the literature have no
on-chip sensors due to the restrictions associated with mi-
cro-fabrication processes [9]. Thus, the in-plane movements
are often measured by laser reflectance microscopes [10, 11]
or optical microscopes [12], making the footprint of the
whole system fairly large. There are several exceptions in
the literature, for example, an embedded on-chip capacitive
displacement sensor was integrated in a thermally actuated
positioner in [13]. Nevertheless, only open-loop results were
obtained, and a complex fabrication process was required
for electrical insulation between electrical heating and sens-
ing circuits. Recently, a thermal sensing scheme was used in
a probe-based storage device [14]. Micro-heaters were used
to measure the motion of a MEMS micro-scanner with reso-
lution of less than 1 nm. Compared to a comb capacitive
sensor, a thermal sensor is more compact and can be easily
integrated with actuators in a MEMS device. In [15, 16],
off-chip electromagnetic coil actuators were adopted for
scanner actuation, and a complex mass-balanced structure
was designed for vibration resistance purposes.
In this paper, a novel electrothermal position sensor is in-
tegrated with a thermal actuator in the same MEMS chip
without the need for inclusion of extra electrical insulation
fabrication process as reported in [13], or assembling two
chips as reported in [15]. Compared to other MEMS actua-
tion mechanisms, the thermal actuators have advantages of
low voltage operation, large forces, and a high vibration
resistance due to their stiff structures [17]. A MEMS device
with integrated electrothermal actuation and sensing has
been micro-fabricated in a bulk silicon process. To reduce
the low frequency thermal drift, the sensors are operated in a
pair and measured by a differential circuitry. The on-chip
displacement sensing enables a feedback control capability.
A model of the positioner is derived and a proportional-
integral (PI) feedback controller is implemented digitally in
a dSPACE rapid prototyping system to investigate the
closed-loop performance of the positioner. Open-loop and
closed-loop step displacement tracking were investigated.
The closed-loop step response results show a positioning
resolution of 7.9 nm and a time constant of 1.6 ms, while the
Design, Prototyping, Modeling and Control of a MEMS
Nanopositioning Stage
Y. Zhu, Member, IEEE, A. Bazaei, S. O. R. Moheimani, Fellow, IEEE, and M. R. Yuce, Senior Mem-
ber, IEEE
H
2011 American Control Conference
on O'Farrell Street, San Francisco, CA, USA
June 29 - July 01, 2011
978-1-4577-0079-8/11/$26.00 ©2011 AACC 2278