Consumption of Alcohol, Nicotine, and Caffeine
Among Depressed Outpatients
Relationship With Response to Treatment
JOHN WORTHINGTON, M.D., MAURIZIO FAVA, M.D.
CHRISTINA AGUSTIN, B.A., JONATHAN ALPERT, M.D., PH.D.
ANDREW A. NIERENBERG, M.D., JOEL A. PAVA, PH.D.
JERROLD F. ROSENBAUM, M.D.
The authors present findings from the first investigation of the use of alcohol, nicotine.
and caffeine in nonsubstance-abusing outpatients with major depressive disorder. The
patients (N =94) were assessed for their intake of alcohol. nicotine. and caffeine. and
then treated openly for 8 weeks with 20 mg/day offluoxetine. The degree of alcohol
consumption at baseline was a significant predictor of poorer response to the antide-
pressant. This relationship remained significant even after adjusting for severity of de-
pression at baseline. Even moderate levels of alcohol consumption appear to
negatively affect pharmacologic treatment in depressed outpatients.
(Psychosomatics 1996; 37:518-522)
M
ajor depressive disorder (MOD) is a
medical illness with a lifetime preva-
lence of 21 % in women and 13% in men.
1
It is
the number one cause of lost workdays, costing
more than $43 billion annually, with an esti-
mated annual cost of actual treatment of $12
billion.
2
Unfortunately, only a small proportion
of those who have MOD ever receive treat-
ment. .1,4 Acommon phenomenon observed among
depressed persons is that of self-medication, using
legal and illegal drugs of various kinds.
5
-
7
While an estimated 14% ofthe U.S. general
population have a history of alcohol abuse or
dependence,
8
20% of men and 10% of women
with primary unipolar depression have an addi-
tional diagnosis of alcoholism.
9
There is a well-
known connection between cigarette smoking
and MOD. The point prevalence of smoking in
depressed outpatients is 49% vs. 30% for normal
control subjects.
7
The data from the St. Louis
5t8
node of the Epidemiologic Catchment Area
(ECA) survey 10 confirm both that MOD is more
common among smokers than among non-
smokers (6.6% vs. 2.9%) and that smokers with
a lifetime history of MOD are less likely to have
succeeded in smoking cessation than are smok-
ers without such a history (14% vs. 28%)."
Finally, caffeine is the most widely used drug in
the world.
12
About 85% of Americans ingest caf-
feine daily, and the average caffeine intake is
approximately 200 mg/day.I3·14 Excessive caffeine
Received January 31, 1995; revised March 24, 1995;
accepted June 2, 1995. From the Depression Research Pro-
gram, Clinical Psychopharmacology Unit, Massachusells
General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston,
Massachusells. Address reprint requests to Dr. Worthington,
Clinical Psychopharmacology Unit. WAC-815, Massachu-
sells General Hospital. 15 Parkman SI., Boston, MA 02114.
Copyright © 1996 The Academy of Psychosomatic
Medicine.
PSYCHOSOMATICS