Reading Research Quarterly • 45(2) • pp. 169–195 • dx.doi.org/10.1598/RRQ.45.2.2 • © 2010 International Reading Association 169
This study investigated 2- and 3-year-olds’ personal interests as a possible source of variation in preschool writing activi-
ties. Structured observations of the play behaviors of 11 preschool children in a childcare classroom were conducted
one to two days per week for one school year. These data were analyzed to determine choices of play activities, material
use, and play actions for each of the children. Naturalistic data collection techniques (e.g., participant observation, video
recording, field notes) were used to record the children’s participation at the classroom writing table two to four days per
week. Video transcripts were microanalyzed to identify the children’s preferred types of writing activities. Findings indi-
cated that patterns in the preschoolers’ profiles of play behaviors reflected conceptual, procedural, creative, or socially
oriented interests and that their personal interest orientations were related to ways they participated in emergent writing
activities. Children with conceptual interests used writing to explore and record ideas on topics of personal interest.
Children with procedural interests explored how writing worked and practiced conventional literacy (e.g., writing alpha-
bet letters). Children with creative interests explored writing materials to generate new literacy processes and new uses
for materials. Children with socially oriented interests used writing to mediate joint social interaction and aligned their
activity choices with those of other participants. These findings suggest that children’s personal interests help shape their
transactions with people, materials, and activities, resulting in different profiles of early writing experiences.
O
ver the last four decades, emergent literacy re-
searchers have established that, early in life,
preschoolers growing up in literate communi-
ties begin to take part in local writing practices (e.g.,
Heath, 1983; Larson, 1999) and to explore writing in
their play (e.g., Baghban, 1984; Martens, 1996; Neuman
& Roskos, 1991). Although we know a good deal about
the kinds of literacy hypotheses children construct
during the preschool years (Rowe, 2008a) and can
identify the positive value of early writing experiences
for later reading and writing (National Early Literacy
Panel, 2008), we know relatively little about the ways
preschoolers actually participate in everyday home or
classroom writing activities. Only a handful of studies
have focused on the writing experiences of children un-
der age 3 (Lancaster, 2003)—the age group of interest
in the current study.
Although existing work with 2- and young 3-year-
olds provides some initial insight into the interactive
strategies children use to jointly construct texts with
adults (Lancaster, 2001, 2007; Rowe, 2008c), there is
limited research describing the literacy activities very
young children choose in preschool classrooms or
why they make these choices (Han, 2007). In addition,
relatively little is known about variability in the ways
preschoolers of any age participate in writing events,
including the ways they exert agency as they take up,
contest, and reshape local writing practices. Research
(Harste, Woodward, & Burke, 1984; Kress, 1997) con-
ducted with 3- to 6-year-olds suggests that preschool-
ers approach writing events to foreground and actively
pursue their own interests. This work suggests that per-
sonal interests may provide a frame through which chil-
dren approach writing events, affecting which topics
and materials children choose to explore (Han, 2007;
Kress, 1997), and even which literacy hypotheses they
test (Harste et al., 1984).
The present study was designed to address two
gaps in the literature. First, we explore personal in-
terests as one possible source of variation in the ways
2- and 3-year-olds participate in writing events. Often,
research has highlighted the powerful role of adults
and cultural practices in shaping very young children’s
participation in local literacy events (e.g., Rowe, 2008c).
In this study, we highlight children’s agency in shap-
ing local writing practices to better align with their
own interests. Second, we explore the relationship
between children’s patterns of play and writing activi-
ties. Research suggests that children may be developing
more general patterns of personal interest that guide
Interest and Agency in 2- and 3-Year-
Olds’ Participation in Emergent Writing
Deborah Wells Rowe, Carin Neitzel
Peabody College, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee, USA
ABSTRACT