PHYSICAL REVIEW B 96, 054421 (2017)
Magnetic aftereffects in CoFeB/Ta/CoFeB spin valves of large area
R. Morgunov,
1, 2 , *
Y. Lu,
3
M. Lavanant,
3
T. Fache,
3
X. Deveaux,
3
S. Migot,
3
O. Koplak,
1
A. Talantsev,
1, 4
and S. Mangin
3
1
Institute of Problems of Chemical Physics, 142432, Chernogolovka, Moscow, Russia
2
Tambov State Technical University, 392000, Tambov, Russia
3
Institut Jean Lamour, UMR 7198 CNRS, Université de Lorraine, 54506 Vandoeuvre, Nancy, France
4
Department of Emerging Materials Science, DGIST, 42988, Daegu, South Korea
(Received 5 February 2017; revised manuscript received 10 July 2017; published 15 August 2017)
Magnetic aftereffect measurements on a synthetic antiferromagnet with strong perpendicular anisotropy are
presented. Two types of magnetic transitions are observed in the CoFeB/Ta/CoFeB bilayer where the two
ferromagnetic CoFeB layers are antiferromagnetically coupled: the transition from a parallel to an antiparallel
CoFeB layers magnetization alignment and the transition between two possible antiparallel magnetization states.
Magnetic relaxation measurements show a complete reversal in the case of the transition between the two
antiferromagnetic configurations. The experimental data can be well fitted in the frame of extended exponential
relaxation using the Fatuzzo-Labrune model. Consequently, the domain nucleation and domain-wall propagation
can be studied as a function of temperature and applied field.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.96.054421
I. INTRODUCTION
Synthetic antiferromagnets (SAFs) with perpendicular
anisotropy (p-SAF) have been designed to be used for
applications in magnetic memory and data storage elements
engineering. Domain-wall dynamics in systems with perpen-
dicular magnetic anisotropy (PMA) attracts much attention for
fundamental studies and potential applications [1,2]. Indeed,
domain-wall motion in thin magnetic films provides interesting
opportunities for the design of high-performance spintronics
devices [1] such as racetrack memories [2], domain-wall logic
circuits [3], and domain-wall nano-oscillators [4]. One of
the physical constraints for fast dynamics is the presence
of the Walker breakdown. The Walker limit corresponds to
the magnetic field threshold value leading to the decrease
of domain-wall velocity under increasing magnetic field [5].
Quite recently, it has been shown through numerical and
analytical modeling that the Walker breakdown limit could be
extended or completely eliminated in antiferromagnetically
coupled magnetic nanowires such as SAF. SAF nanowires
would allow high domain-wall velocity driven by field and/or
current as compared to conventional nanowires.
In this context, we focused on the analyses of magnetization
dynamics in a model CoFeB/Ta/CoFeB bilayer. It consists of
two ultrathin antiferromagnetically exchange-coupled ferro-
magnetic CoFeB layers with strong perpendicular anisotropy.
The multilayer stack was grown directly on a GaAs substrate.
Quasistatic magnetization versus field hysteresis loops were
measured for different temperatures ranging from 5 to 300 K.
It allowed a field-temperature (H -T ) magnetization switching
diagram to be constructed [6]. Now we would like to focus
on the magnetization dynamics during the transition from one
magnetic state to the other. Domain-wall dynamics in p-SAF
systems is very unusual [1,2] and becomes more complicated
for multilayered samples.
Another feature of thin spin valves is very unusual exponen-
tial relaxation [7] indicating single-potential barrier relief for
*
Corresponding author: morgunov2005@yandex.ru
domain walls. Observation of reversal magnetization dynamics
in single ferromagnetic layers and its comparison with that in
the double-ferromagnetic-layer system allows one to judge
the contribution of the interlayer interaction to domain-wall
dynamics.
Many papers are focused on time-dependent switching of
the multilayered heterostructure in the nanosecond scale [1–4].
The damping parameter governs effectiveness of switching of
Giant Magnetoresistance devices and their convenience for
high-frequency readout in the microwave frequency range.
The results mentioned above relate to nanosized spin valves
designed for memory cells. Reversal magnetization of these
small devices obeys the macrospin approach. Meanwhile,
magnetic nanoparticles sensor technology requires larger
areas of devices for better resolution and sensitivity to
magnetic field. The magnetic aftereffect in these struc-
tures has a larger time scale and magnetization reversal
cannot be considered in terms of the macrospin model
only.
In the present paper, we will pay attention to another
problem, which dramatically affects the quality of the large
(∼1–10 mm
2
) area of CoFeB multilayered structures. Thin
ferromagnetic layers as well as CoFeB multilayered struc-
tures manifest slow magnetic relaxation due to domain-wall
dynamics [8]. In [8], magneto-optic Kerr effect (MOKE)
microscopy of those samples studied in this paper was
reported. This process is very complicated due to the ther-
mally activated character of the domain-wall unpinning,
peculiar interaction between ferromagnetic layers, and inho-
mogeneous distribution of magnetization through the layer
[Fig. 1(a)].
In this paper, we present a detailed study of the time-
resolved (for time ranging from seconds) response of mag-
netization in the CoFeB/Ta/CoFeB bilayer and the CoFeB
single-layer samples as a function of temperature and applied
magnetic field. Similarities and differences between single-
layer magnetization reversal and double-layer simultaneous
reversal (direct transition between the antiparallel magnetic
states: AP + and AP −) in the CoFeB/Ta/CoFeB bilayer will
be discussed. The goals of the paper are as follows:
2469-9950/2017/96(5)/054421(10) 054421-1 ©2017 American Physical Society