Vinod Suresh
Joseph C. Anderson
James B. Grotberg
Department of Biomedical Engineering,
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109
Ronald B. Hirschl
Department of Surgery, University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI 48109
A Mathematical Model of Alveolar
Gas Exchange in Partial Liquid
Ventilation
In partial liquid ventilation (PLV), perfluorocarbon (PFC) acts as a diffusion barrier to
gas transport in the alveolar space since the diffusivities of oxygen and carbon dioxide in
this medium are four orders of magnitude lower than in air. Therefore convection in the
PFC layer resulting from the oscillatory motions of the alveolar sac during ventilation
can significantly affect gas transport. For example, a typical value of the Pe ´clet number
in air ventilation is Pe;0.01, whereas in PLV it is Pe;20. To study the importance of
convection, a single terminal alveolar sac is modeled as an oscillating spherical shell
with gas, PFC, tissue and capillary blood compartments. Differential equations describ-
ing mass conservation within each compartment are derived and solved to obtain time
periodic partial pressures. Significant partial pressure gradients in the PFC layer and
partial pressure differences between the capillary and gas compartments ~ P
C
-P
g
! are
found to exist. Because Pe@1, temporal phase differences are found to exist between
P
C
-P
g
and the ventilatory cycle that cannot be adequately described by existing non-
convective models of gas exchange in PLV. The mass transfer rate is nearly constant
throughout the breath when Pe@1, but when Pe!1 nearly 100% of the transport occurs
during inspiration. A range of respiratory rates (RR), including those relevant to high
frequency oscillation (HFO)1PLV, tidal volumes ~ V
T
! and perfusion rates are studied to
determine the effect of heterogeneous distributions of ventilation and perfusion on gas
exchange. The largest changes in P
C
O
2
and P
C
CO
2
occur at normal and low perfusion
rates respectively as RR and V
T
are varied. At a given ventilation rate, a low RR-high V
T
combination results in higher P
C
O
2
, lower P
C
CO
2
and lower ~ P
C
-P
g
! than a high
RR-low V
T
one. @DOI: 10.1115/1.1835352#
Keywords: Partial Liquid Ventilation, Liquid Breathing, Perfluorocarbon, Gas Ex-
change, Convection
1 Introduction
Liquid breathing in mammals using perfluorocarbon ~PFC! was
first demonstrated by Clark and Gollan @1#. Since then the concept
has led to the development of partial liquid ventilation ~PLV! as a
promising alternative to conventional mechanical gas ventilation
~GV! for treating acute respiratory distress syndrome ~ARDS! and
acute lung injury ~ALI!. Studies on animal models @2–6# and
human trials @7–11# have indicated improvement in gas exchange
and lung compliance associated with the use of PLV.
Recent studies have examined the effects of PLV on regional
ventilation ( V
˙
A
) and blood flow ( Q
˙
) distribution in the lung in
order to understand the mechanisms behind the global changes in
gas exchange and lung mechanics. PFC was found to be predomi-
nantly distributed in the dependent regions of injured adult sheep
lungs undergoing PLV and more gas than PFC was found to be
present in the nondependent regions of the lung @6#. Redistribution
of blood flow from the dependent to the nondependent regions of
the lung was observed during PLV in lambs @12# and pigs @13#.
Ventilation-perfusion ( V
˙
A
/ Q
˙
) inhomogeneity was found to be
higher during PLV compared to GV in healthy piglets @14#. Sig-
nificant regions with low V
˙
A
/ Q
˙
ratios were observed in rabbits
with acute lung injury during PLV @15#. Harris et al. @16# com-
pared regional distributions of ventilation, blood flow, and
ventilation-perfusion ratio in the normal lung of a sheep during
PLV and GV. They found that both ventilation and perfusion are
shifted from the dependent regions to the nondependent regions of
the lung in PLV, leading to a wide distribution of V
˙
A
/ Q
˙
in differ-
ent regions of the lung. In contrast V
˙
A
/ Q
˙
ratios were close to
unity over most of the lung in GV. In order to understand the
mechanisms responsible for improved gas exchange in PLV, it is
crucial to determine the contribution to gas exchange of regions
whose V
˙
A
, Q
˙
, and V
˙
A
/ Q
˙
differ significantly from their normal
values in GV.
Previous animal studies indicated enhanced arterial-alveolar
( a - A ) partial pressure gradients in PLV as a result of increased
shunt fraction and ventilation-perfusion heterogeneity @14#. Van-
Lo ¨bensels et al. developed a mathematical model of gas exchange
during PLV in lung subunits with a PFC layer that indicated a
diffusion limitation could lead to significant ( a - A ) gradients @17#.
However they only considered diffusion of respiratory gases
through a stagnant layer of PFC in an alveolar sac. In reality the
expansion and contraction of the sac during tidal ventilation cre-
ates a flow field within the PFC layer contained inside. The im-
portance of convective effects on transport can be estimated
through the Pe ´clet number, Pe52 p fR
2
/ D, where f is the breath-
ing frequency in breaths/second, R is the sac radius, and D is the
gas diffusivity in the alveolar medium ~air in GV, PFC, in PLV!.
Values of Pe@1 indicate that convection plays a significant role in
transport while values of Pe!1 indicate that diffusion is the domi-
nant transport mechanism. At normal respiratory rates, Pe
;10
23
– 10
22
in GV while it is on the order of 15–50 in PLV.
This is a result of the small diffusivities of O
2
and CO
2
in PFC,
which are 1000–10,000 times smaller than in air. Thus convective
effects play an important role in the transport of respiratory gases
Contributed by the Bioengineering Division for publication in the JOURNAL OF
BIOMECHANICAL ENGINEERING. Manuscript received by the Bioengineering Divi-
sion December 1, 2003; revision received September 8, 2004. Associate Editor:
James Moore.
46 Õ Vol. 127, FEBRUARY 2005 Copyright © 2005 by ASME Transactions of the ASME