© 2001 Blackwell Science Ltd International Journal of Consumer Studies, 25, 1, March 2001, pp43–52
|
43
Perception of food safety and changes in food
consumption habits: a consumer analysis
Arbindra Rimal
1
, Stanley M. Fletcher
2
, K. H. McWatters
3
, Sukant K. Misra
4
and S. Deodhar
5
1 Department of Agriculture-Agribusiness Southwest Missouri State University
2 Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, The University of Georgia
3 Department of Food Science and Technology, The Unversity of Georgia
4 Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, Texas Tech University
5 Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad, India
50% of the respondents said they preferred to buy
organically grown fresh fruits and vegetables, yet only a
quarter said they actually bought them on a regular
basis.
3
In the USA, many local and national surveys have
revealed consumer concern regarding fat and choles-
terol content of foods, pesticides and microbial conta-
mination. Such concerns are likely to translate into
market behaviour. Therefore, food industry and gov-
ernment policy makers will have to respond to con-
sumers’ health concerns without significantly increasing
costs to them.
4
In this regard, inconsistency in consumer
attitude and behaviour becomes particularly important.
The Alar controversy associated with apples in 1989 and
the post-Alar phenomenon revealed that although con-
sumers expressed concern about food safety, they were
not willing to pay a premium price for organically grown
food or to accept cosmetic damage.
5
This raises
the question as to how the industry should respond
to consumer safety concerns. Food irradiation, for
example, is a likely response to consumers’ safety
concern that has not been widely adopted by the indus-
try due to the uncertainty about consumer acceptance.
According to Packer magazine, some consumers altered
their buying habits between 1989 and 1990 due to the
concern about pesticide residues in fresh produce,
although the change was not significant. In contrast,
more than 50% of the respondents in a University of
Georgia survey maintained their purchase pattern of
fresh produce despite the perceived high risks from pes-
ticide residues.
6
In this study, the relationship between
seven types of food safety concerns and the corre-
sponding change in food consumption habits is evalu-
ated. First, the study examines the gap between public
concerns and corresponding change in food consump-
tion habits. Second, it evaluates the impact of socio-
economic and attitude variables on perceived food
safety threats and on behavioural response to food
safety threats.
Abstract
The relationship between seven types of food safety con-
cerns and the corresponding change in food consumption
habits of 236 households in Georgia, USA was evaluated.
Results showed a gap between food safety concerns and
food consumption habits. Gaps were particularly evident
in the cases of pesticide residues, animal drug residues,
growth hormones and bacteria. For example, more than 54%
of sample households were extremely concerned about pes-
ticide residues, but only 35% actually took extreme precau-
tion in buying items considering this perceived threat. The
study indicated that educating consumers about preventive
methods to reduce food safety threats will lead to reduced
concerns and changes in food consumption habits.
Keywords Food safety concern, consumption habit, know-
ledge, demographics.
Introduction
Consumers’ actual behaviour is often inconsistent with
their reported attitudes or concerns. This is particularly
true with regard to health risks. Many consumers
express concern about food safety, yet relatively few
appear to be changing their food buying behaviour
in view of their concern.
1
For example, a survey by
the NPD (National Panel Diary) group in the USA
evaluating the gap between consumer attitude and
behaviour reported that people expressing concern
about health problems associated with french fry con-
sumption rose to 39% between 1985 and 1990, yet the
number eating them at least once in 2 weeks declined
just 7%.
2
In a national survey in the USA, more than
Correspondence
A. Rimal, 206 Karls Hall, Southwest Missouri State University, 901 South
National Avenue, Springfield, MO 65804, USA. E-mail:
arr412f@smsu.edu