Simulation study on micro and macro mechanical behaviour of sand piles
Pradip Roul
a,
⁎, Alexander Schinner
b
a
Institute for Numerical Mathematics, Duisburg-Essen University, D-47058, Duisburg, Germany
b
T-Systems, Dachauer Strasse 665, D-80995, Germany
abstract article info
Available online 5 August 2010
Keywords:
Discrete element method
Sand pile
Representative volume element
Stress
Strain
Fabric
We investigate numerically the micro and macro mechanical behaviour of non-cohesive granular materials,
especially in the static limit. To achieve this goal we performed numerical simulations generating two-
dimensional “sand piles” from several thousands of convex polygonal particles with varying shapes, sizes
and corner numbers, using a discrete element approach based on soft particles. We emphasize that the
displacement (strain) fields inside sand piles have not been measured in experiments on sand piles.
Averaging is made reproducible by introducing a representative volume element (RVE), the size of which we
determine by careful measurements. Stress tensors are studied for both symmetric and asymmetric sand
piles in two-dimensional systems, where the particles are dropped from a point source. Furthermore, we
determine the fabric tensor inside the sand piles. A surprising finding is the behaviour of the contact density
in this kind of heap, which increases where the pressure is at a minimum. The fabric is linearly proportional
to the product of the volume fraction and the mean coordination number for a pile consisting of mono-
disperse mixture of particles. We observe that the macroscopic stress, strain and fabric tensors are not
collinear in the sand piles.
© 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Granular materials are of fundamental importance and high
interest to various branches of science and technology such as
physics, applied mathematics and mechanics. In recent years,
considerable interest in granular materials has been stimulated due
to their high technological relevance: many products exist as a
granulate at some stage of their processing history. Currently, a large
amount of money is spent on the transportation and processing
associated with the storage and containment of granular materials.
However, about 50% of the money is unnecessarily spent because of
problems related to the transport of the material from one part of the
factory to another part of the factory.
Now, to have a look from another angle, it is often assumed that
the side wall of a material container receives a constant force from the
granular material inside. The common example of this issue is a model
of a silo which is of great concern to various industries such as
agricultural, pharmaceutical and mining industries, and all construc-
tion-based industries. However, this assumption is wrong, and in the
general case, forces are non-uniformly propagated within the
material, so they are also non-uniformly distributed at the wall of
the silo. In some cases, if the force is much larger in some parts of the
container than in other parts, the silo might collapse. For in order to
avoid problems such as the collapse or breach of a silo, one can simply
increase the thickness of the walls by a generously chosen safety
margin, which would be unnecessary if we had the knowledge how to
design the silo in a proper way, especially taking into account the
expected distribution of forces inside the silo. Therefore, the
understanding of the basic physical principles behind the stress
distribution in static granular materials is clearly important.
A simple example out of a collection of granular arrangements is
the static sand pile. The formation of a sand pile is related to the
fundamental behaviour of granular materials, including particle
packing, segregation and pressure distribution [1–8]. The practice of
storing granular materials in the form of sand piles occurs in many
industrial situations dealing with particulate materials. Examples
include the pharmaceutical industry relying on the processing of
powders and tablets, the agricultural industry, coal industry and the
food processing industries where seeds, coal (grain) and foods are
transported and manipulated. Moreover, the storing of the material in
a pile may be useful in fertilizer and mining industries. Thus, the flow
of granular materials through a funnel (to form a pile) is an important
problem for many industrial processes.
In order to handle the processing of granular materials in a pile
properly, it is important to understand its mechanical properties. On the
other hand, the study of deformation of granular materials either under
external loading or unloading is also of practical importance for many
industries. Although some progress has been made in this field during
last ten years, these properties are still far from being exhaustively
understood. Moreover, continuum models proposing constitutive
Powder Technology 204 (2010) 113–123
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: + 49 17620961836; fax: + 49203 3792689
E-mail address: pradip.roul@uni-due.de (P. Roul).
0032-5910/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.powtec.2010.07.026
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Powder Technology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/powtec