DOI: 10.1111/mepo.12572
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Shii-Kurd Relations in Post-2003 Iraq:
Visions of Nationalism
Elisheva Machlis
Dr. Machlis is a senior lecturer in Middle
East Studies at Bar-Ilan University, Israel.
Abstract
Regime change in Iraq provided a new opportunity for
Shiis and Kurds to create a new power-sharing sys-
tem. These two persecuted communities embraced a
democratic-federal system based on a combined civic
and ethnocultural model. Analyzing this new alliance,
this article argues that there were prominent forces
within both communities that did not uphold an essen-
tialist sense of identity, thus providing a basis for mutual
recognition, as reflected in the new constitution. How-
ever, while in theory there was room for mitigating
sectarian and ethnic boundaries, in practice, the dif-
ferences assumed a much larger place, as reflected in
the power struggle between Baghdad and Erbil. The
process of unifying Iraq lacked an in-depth debate
over the place of diverse national narratives, together
with an effort toward people-to-people contact. Concur-
rently, the struggle against the jihadists enhanced Shii-
Kurdish interdependency, while the battle of Kirkuk led
to greater pragmatism. Post-2003 Iraq provides a chal-
lenging case of democratization and regime change, due
to the need for a delicate balancing act between power
and multiple visions of religion and ethnic identity while
contemplating multiple visions of nationalism.
MIDDLE EAST POLICY. 2021;1–17. © 2021 The Middle East Policy Council 1 wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/mepo