ICHNOLOGY OF THE BRIDGE CREEK LIMESTONE: EVIDENCE FOR
TEMPORAL AND SPATIAL VARIATIONS IN PALEO-OXYGENATION
IN THE WESTERN INTERIOR SEAWAY
CHARLES E. SAVRDA
Department of Geology, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849-5305
ABSTRACT: The Upper Cretaceous (Cenomanian-Turonian) Bridge Creek Limestone is characterized by decimeter-scale alternation of pelagic lime-
stones and marly shales that were deposited under variably oxygenated waters. Vertical stacking patterns of laminites and four oxygen-related ichnocoenoses
in the Bridge Creek in two coresUSGS #1 Portland from east-central Colorado and Amoco #1 Rebecca K. Bounds from western Kansasprovide a
record of both temporal and spatial changes in benthic oxygenation within the distal offshore parts of the Western Interior Seaway.
Paleo-oxygenation histories reconstructed for the Portland core reflect: (1) a broad trend towards decreased benthic oxygenation through the entire
Bridge Creek interval; (2) a high-amplitude redox cyclicity that corresponds to limestone/marly shale couplets; and (3) a higher-frequency, lower-amplitude
redox cyclicity expressed within the marly shale intervals.
Trends (1) and (2) are well expressed in the Bounds core. However, bioturbated horizons in marly shale intervals are less common, thinner, of lower
ichnocoenosis rank, or absent altogether. This pattern indicates that paleo-oxygenation levels were lower at the Bounds locality, at least during
clastic-dominated phases of depositional cycles, and may reflect higher productivity and oxygen demand in the eastern part of the basin.
INTRODUCTION
The rhythmically bedded Bridge Creek Limestone Member
of the Greenhorn Formation represents one of two Upper Creta-
ceous intervals targeted for detailed study as part of the Creta-
ceous Western Interior Seaway Drilling Project. Among many
other objectives (Dean and Arthur, this volume), this
multidisciplinary research program was undertaken to better es-
tablish the mechanisms responsible for depositional cyclicity and
to determine controls on accumulation -rate, character, and
preservational state of organic matter in the Western Interior
basin. Attainment of these and related goals depends, in part, on
our ability to evaluate how benthic oxygenation levels varied
through time and space.
Benthic oxygenation is an important oceanographic param-
eter that may reflect aspects of oceanic circulation, some of which
may be mediated by climate (e.g., upwelling intensity, degree
of
thermohaline density stratification, etc.), and exerts significant
control over the quantity and preservational state of organic matter
in marine deposits. Oxygenation is also one of the most crucial
factors influencing the character and activities of benthic organ-
isms in quiet marine settings. Fortunately, the response of
bioturbating infauna to variations in benthic oxygenation are
preserved and reflected by ichnological parameters. Hence, by
serving as proxy indicators of paleo-redox conditions, ichnofabrics
of hemipelagic and pelagic strata can play a significant role in
paleoceanographic reconstructions and source-rock studies.
With this as incentive, I analyzed ichnofabrics and compo-
nent ichnofossils at the centimeter scale throughout the Bridge
Creek interval of two cores: USGS #1 Portland in east-central
Colorado and Amoco #1 Rebecca K. Bounds in western Kansas
(Dean and Arthur, this volume). The objectives of this paper are
to (1) summarize the ichnologic data collected during these
stud-
ies and (2) discuss their general implications for both temporal
patterns (long-term trends and higher-frequency cycles)
and spa-
tial variations in benthic oxygenation in the offshore part of the
Western Interior Seaway.
BRIDGE CREEK LIMESTONE
General Framework
The Cenomanian-Turonian Bridge Creek Limestone Mem-
ber of the Greenhorn Formation records deposition in distal off-
Stratigraphy and Paleoenvironments of the Cretaceous Western Interior Seaway, USA, SEPM Concepts in Sedimentology and
Paleontology No. 6
Copyright 1998 SEPM (Society for Sedimentary Geology), ISBN 1-56576-044-1, p. 127-136.
shore settings of the Western Interior Seaway during a major
transgressive episode (Elder and Kirkland, 1985; Elder et al.,
1994). The Bridge Creek Limestone, which is approximately 15
m thick on average (Eicher and Diner, 1989), overlies the
Hartland Shale Member of the Greenhorn Formation and is over-
lain by the Fairport Member of the Carlile Shale (Elder and
Kirkland, 1985; Hattin, 1985). In Colorado, the Bridge Creek
Limestone is subdivided into three units (lower, middle, and
upper Bridge Creek; Pratt, 1984; Elder and Kirkland, 1985),
which are generally equivalent to the upper Hartland, Jetrnore,
and Pfiefer Members of the Greenhorn Limestone as defmed
in Kansas (Hattin, 1985). Delineation of these units is based pri-
marily upon bedding characteristics and minor lithological vari-
ability (see Elder and Kirkland, 1985).
As a whole, the Bridge Creek is characterized by well-defmed,
decimeter-scale rhythmic alternation of highly bioturbated,
organic-poor, micritic limestones and laminated to bioturbated,
organic-rich marlstones and marly shales (Pratt, 1984; Arthur et
al., 1985; Elder and Kirkland, 1985; Arthur and Dean, 1991;
Pratt et al., 1993). Subordinate lithological components include
numerous bentonites, derived from the volcanic arc to the west,
and calcarenites of variable thickness (Pratt, 1984; Elder, 1985).
Bentonites, as well as prominent limestone beds, can be traced
over a large area of the Western Interior and define
lithochronozones within which spatial changes in sedimentation
patterns can be assessed (Hattin, 1985; Elder and Kirkland, 1985;
Elder et al., 1994). Calcarenites, which are attributed to
bottom-current winnowing, are relatively minor components of
the lower and middle units, but are extremely abundant in and
diagnostic of the upper Bridge Creek (Pratt, 1984).
Carbonate Cyclicity
Decimeter-scale rhythmicity in the Bridge Creek tradition-
ally has been interpreted to be the product of orbitally driven
climate cycles (Gilbert, 1895; Hattin, 1975; Kauffman, 1977;
Fischer, 1980; Barron et al., 1985). However, there is consider-
able disagreement regarding the primary paleoceanographic
mechanisms responsible for these carbonate rhythms. Bridge
Creek carbonate oscillations are attributed to combined produc-
tivity/redox cycles that may be linked to climate-driven changes
in density stratification of the Tethys to the south (Eicher and
Diner, 1989, 1991; Ricken, 1991, 1994). Alternatively, carbon-
ate rhythms may record combined dilution-redox cycles associ-
127
Copyright © 2012, The Society for Sedimentary Geology (SEPM)