Session F1A
0-7803-7444-4/02/$17.00 © 2002 IEEE November 6 - 9, 2002, Boston, MA
32
nd
ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference
F1A-1
A MATHEMATICAL MODEL FOR REUSING STUDENT LEARNING SKILLS
ACROSS DIDACTICAL UNITS
M. Carmen Fernández Panadero
1
, Abelardo Pardo
1
, Javier Fernández Panadero
1
,
Andrés Marín López
1
1
Carlos III University of Madrid (UC3M), Avda. Universidad, 30. 28911 Leganés. Madrid. {mcfp, abel, amarin}@it.uc3m.es, javierf.p.@wanadoo.es
Abstract In this paper a mathematical model to capture
information about learning capabilities of students for
reusing across didactical units is presented. The model is
based on the definition of a set of generic objectives related
to the concepts, skills and attitudes the student is expected to
assimilate by the end of a unit. Each objective is represented
as an axis in a n-dimensional mathematical space. A
relationship is established between the topics and each of
the objectives. The grading process is modified to reflect
how the student performs with respect to these objectives.
The expected and obtained grades are then represented in
this mathematical space. The proposed model provides
support for diagnostics, facilitates the course
characterization and comparison (even adaptive ones) and
is suitable to be adopted in both new and on-going courses,
because requires only the definition of the relationship
between topics, evaluation and objectives.
Index Terms user modeling, evaluation, course
sequencing, learning skills, adaptability.
INTRODUCTION
Today's computer science and computer engineering
curricula include a significant part of student assignments.
Grading of such assignments provide insight not only into
the students’ proficiency but also into their generic learning
capabilities. This information is typically used only at the
course level. However, information about generic learning
capabilities is very valuable toward providing a degree of
personalization across different courses.
There has been a significant effort to encourage the
reuse of educational material across different courses and
educational institutions. There is an equally important
potential in reusing the information obtained during the
evaluation process. But, as in the case of reuse of
educational material, the main challenge is to provide a
framework simple enough to facilitate its adoption and at the
same time powerful enough to justify its use.
Students encounter similar difficulties in different
courses. This is specially true in engineering education since
courses are extremely related. In this paper we present a
mathematical model to capture through evaluation
information about generic learning capabilities of each
student for reusing accross didactical units. The model is
suitable to be adopted in both new and on-going courses
because requires only the definition of the relationship
between topics, evaluation and objetives.
The rest of the paper is structured as follows. First a
brief introduction to user modeling and model reusability is
outlined. Next, both the model and the evaluation process is
presented. Finally, conclusions and future research venues
are discused.
RELATED RESEARCH
In 1984 Bloom [1] reported that students working with a
“good” human tutor obtained an average performance two
standard desviations higher than students in conventional
instruction. This is known as “The 2 Sigma Problem”. Since
1984 several research groups studied how to acomplish the
same performance under more practical conditions than the
one-to-one tutoring. In [2] Corbett proposes to accomplish
this by customizing certain aspects like content, feedback, or
providing personalized instruction pacing.
All these techniques require an underlying student
model or student profile that allows to diagnose the student
characteristics, such as skills and knowledge level. There are
multiple studies on how to collect information to create a
student profile (i.e. background knowledge, experience,
plans, preferences, etc) [3]. This student profile is tightly
coupled with the course so each new course requires a
different model.
Reusing student models accross different courses would
simplify this task, but a significant effort is required to
define models suitable to be used in different contexts. The
first step in this direction has been to create integrated
environments such as WebCT [4], Blackboard [5] or
TopClass [6] that allow the creation of course content and
offer facilities to collect student information. These
platforms can reuse student information as long as the course
remains in the same platform. Taking student information
from one platform to another remains being a difficult task .
In the last decade there have been several groups like
IEEE P1484.2 [7] or IMS project [8] devoted to specify
generic user models (PAPI and IMS Learner Information