PARAFAC model as an innovative tool for monitoring
natural organic matter removal in water treatment plants
Sikelelwa N. Ndiweni, Michael Chys, Nhamo Chaukura,
Stijn W. H. Van Hulle and Thabo T. I. Nkambule
ABSTRACT
The increase of fluorescent natural organic matter ( fNOM) fractions during drinking water treatment
might lead to an increased coagulant dose and filter clogging, and can be a precursor for disinfection
by-products. Consequently, efficient fNOM removal is essential, for which characterisation of fNOM
fractions is crucial. This study aims to develop a robust monitoring tool for assessing fNOM fractions
across water treatment processes. To achieve this, water samples were collected from six South
African water treatment plants (WTPs) during winter and summer, and two plants in Belgium during
spring. The removal of fNOM was monitored by assessing fluorescence excitation–emission matrices
datasets using parallel factor analysis. The removal of fNOM during summer for South African WTPs
was in the range 69–85%, and decreased to 42–64% in winter. In Belgian WTPs, fNOM removal was
in the range 74–78%. Principal component analysis revealed a positive correlation between total
fluorescence and total organic carbon (TOC). However, TOC had an insignificant contribution to the
factors affecting fNOM removal. Overall, the study demonstrated the appearance of fNOM in the final
chlorinated water, indicating that fNOM requires a customised monitoring technique.
Sikelelwa N. Ndiweni
Nhamo Chaukura
Thabo T. I. Nkambule (corresponding
author)
Nanotechnology and Water Sustainability Research
Unit, College of Science, Engineering and
Technology,
University of South Africa,
Florida Campus, 1709, Johannesburg,
South Africa
E-mail: nkambtt@unisa.ac.za
Michael Chys
†
Stijn W. H. Van Hulle
LIWET, Department of Green Chemistry and
Technology,
Ghent University,
Campus Kortrijk, Graaf Karel de Goedelaan 5,
B-8500 Kortrijk,
Belgium
†
Present address: VEG-i-TEC, Ghent University,
Campus Kortrijk, Graaf Karel De Goedelaan 5,
B-8500 Kortrijk, Belgium
Key words | excitation–emission matrices, fluorescent natural organic matter, parallel factor
analysis, protein to humic ratio, water treatment processes
INTRODUCTION
Natural organic matter (NOM) in water sources reduces the
performance of water treatment plants (WTPs), downgrades
water quality, and increases operational costs (Sillanpaa
et al. ). Fluorescent natural organic matter ( fNOM) is lar-
gely made up of humic-like, fulvic-like, and protein-like
components (Shao et al. ). Currently, parameters used
for tracking recalcitrant fNOM are turbidity, total organic
carbon (TOC), UV
254
, pH, and conductivity (Ndiweni et al.
). However, these monitoring tools do not have capabili-
ties to reveal enough information to fast track the removal of
problematic fNOM fractions. For instance, online turbidity
measurements for raw water were proven to be unreliable
compared to tryptophan-like (tryp-like) and humic-like
fluorescence (FL) measurements (Sorensen et al. ).
A conventional WTP commonly uses different water treat-
ment stages such as coagulation, sedimentation, sand filtration
(SF), and chlorination. The effects of fNOM on water treat-
ment include fouling of filtration media such as membranes
and activated carbon (AC) (Shao et al. ). Moreover,
during coagulation, flocculation, filtration, ozonation and
chlorination, fNOM fractions can transform to form secondary
products, which are more toxic and complex compared to the
parent compounds (Brumer et al. ). Secondary product
refers to compounds formed when ozone breaks down large
molecules to small molecules that exhibit varying character-
istics. Secondary product can also be used to refer to product
formed when fNOM fractions react with chlorine disinfection
by-products (DBPs), which are potentially formed (Chaukura
et al. ). When traces of biodegradable fNOM are present
in the chlorination stage, there is a possibility of bacterial
regrowth and corrosion in the water distribution system
(Baghoth & Amy ). These DBPs such as trihalomethanes
and haloacetic acids stimulate cancer cells in humans; hence
when optimising WTPs it is important to ensure that water is
safe for consumption (Haarhoff et al. ).
Analysing unknown heterogeneous fNOM, some of which
can occur at low relative concentrations or below detection
limit, is a challenge (Liu et al. ). In order to identify
1786 © IWA Publishing 2020 Water Science & Technology | 81.8 | 2020
doi: 10.2166/wst.2020.136
Downloaded from http://iwaponline.com/wst/article-pdf/81/8/1786/710307/wst081081786.pdf
by guest
on 05 November 2021