24
Humans as Components of Ecosystems:
A Synthesis
Steward T.A. Pickett and Mark J. McDonnell
Introduction
The call for including humans as components of ecological research is not
new. As we described in Chapter 1, the obvious negative impacts of human
activities have been well documented, but the more subtle causes and
effects of humans on ecosystems have not traditionally been the subject of
study by North American ecologists. Similarly, human populated areas are
typically not considered within the research domain of ecologists. Ironically,
however, the very first paper published in the Ecological Society of
America's journal, Ecology, was on the influence of weather on infection
rates of pneumonia and influenza in the citizens of New York City and
Boston (Huntington 1920). Since Huntington's paper, there have been
relatively few studies that include humans as part of an ecological system
published in the journal. The relative lack of ecological research that
includes humans may reflect a long-standing tension in ecology (Kingsland
1985) between historical and instantaneous approaches.
One of the earliest calls for including humans as components of ecologi-
cal study by a North American ecologist was by Charles C. Adams (1935,
1938). Some 50 years ago, Adams (1938:501) stated time is rapidly
approaching when ecologists-or others more alert to the true ecological
situation-will be called upon to assist in a fresh integration of the biological
and the social sciences· in order to more effectively assess the influence of
human activities on the environment. This call has been echoed by other
ecologists including Curtis (1956), Holling and Orians (1971), Stearns and
Montag (1974), Bornkamm et al. (1982), Ehrlich (1985), Brown and
Roughgarden (1989), and McDonnell and Pickett (1990). The recent
appearance of a new North American journal entitled Ecological Applica-
tions is yet another indication that ecologists are willing to broaden the
scope of the field to explicitly include human activities. Unfortunately, in
310
M. J. McDonnell et al. (eds.), Humans as Components of Ecosystems
© Springer-Verlag New York, Inc. 1993