157
14
THE PHD PROCESS:
DOCTOR OR DOCTORED?
Kasturi Behari-Leak
INTRODUCTION
The doctoral journey has been the most profound and intense intellectual and
emotional engagement I have had in my academic life. It is fitting that the PhD
graduation ceremony, which is the culmination of years of intellectual endurance and
perseverance, is filled with tradition and ceremony. The four-year doctoral journey is
similar to the four-minute walk across the stage to be capped and hooded. Stepping
onto the stage is like stepping into the doctoral space. Walking across the stage
requires that you are mindful of the audience – as you have to be with the reader of
the thesis. Being acknowledged by the university through its conferring of the degree
is synonymous with academic peer review. Finally facing the academic community
is like coming through the examination process. All these physical movements
during graduation embody the stages in the doctoral journey from conception of
the research question, to the final submission of the thesis for examination, and then
to graduation.
Standing there, finely kitted out in academic gown and regalia, the more pressing
and immediate task was walking across the stage. What if I tripped over myself in my
eagerness to make it to the other end as Doctor Behari-Leak? I had just completed
an intellectual marathon to the finish line, so the short “walk to freedom” could not
be that involved, could it? As I made my way to the chancellor to be capped, I faced
a huge dilemma. If I knelt down onto the low stool, would I be able to stand up
again given that I was wearing a saree, which is a traditional Indian outfit? Would
my cultural trappings result, literally, in my downfall? If my saree did get caught,
would I be stuck there, frozen in time, half capped, not hooded? The weightier issue
was that submitting or kneeling down to anyone was not something I did very well,
so how would I succumb and humble myself before this esteemed chancellor of
the university?
Frick L, Motshoane C, McMaster C, Murphy C (eds) 2016. Postgraduate Study in South Africa. Stellenbosch: SUN PRESS
DOI: 10.18820/9781928357247/14 © 2017 AFRICAN SUN MeDIA