1
Int. J. Architect. Eng. Urban Plan, 31(1): 1-11 January 2021
DOI: 10.22068/ijaup.iust.2020.101
Research Paper
A Critical Investigation of Priorities in Adaptive Reuse Theories within the Interior
Architecture of Valuable Buildings: A Comparative Study based on
the Nara Document Parameters
Seyed Ehsan Masoud
1
, Alireza Einifar
2*
1
PhD. Candidate, School of Architecture and Environmental Design, Iran University of Science and Technology,
Tehran, Iran
2
Professor of Architecture, School of Architecture, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
Received: May 2020, Revised: June 2020, Accepted: June 2020, Publish Online: July 2020
Abstract
Changing and repurposing existing buildings for their continued use was quite common in the past and structurally safe
buildings were adapted to meet new functions and needs. In modern conservation theory, Adaptive Reuse is an important
means of preserving cultural heritage. The main question is what are the priorities and shortcomings of adaptive reuse
theoretical references within interior architecture based on comparative study with Nara Document parameters. The research
method of this study is qualitative, with logical argument as a strategy. The priorities were studied and then the most important
weaknesses and drawbacks of these approaches to Adaptive Reuse were analyzed in a comparative study with the Nara Grid
by 32 semi-structured interviews with experts in the fields of Architecture, Interior architecture and conservation. The results
show four main Adaptive Reuse priorities extracted from the reviewed literature: Host Space Function, Programmatic
Approach to New Use, Technical Requirements and Design-oriented strategies and solutions. These theoretical priorities do
not negate each other; in fact, they are rather complementary. However, if one of them gains more importance in the process it
can lead to many losses. Of their most important disadvantages, the following are worth mentioning: A physical outlook and a
lack of attention to intangible and soft values, a lack of attention to the meaning and characteristics of functions of the building
in the past, ignoring the human presence and its needs, ignoring architectural details and interior architecture, lack of
interdisciplinary research, and lack of adequate strategies in line with building values. It seems like the issues mentioned
above could be avoided and redeemed through an emphasis in conservation policy on fixed feature spaces, semi-fixed feature
spaces, and informal spaces in interior spaces, as well as considering human needs and social sciences in the redesign
process, and following each priority and approach in the redesign process accordingly.
Keywords: Adaptive Reuse, Valuable Buildings, Interior Architecture, Priorities, Nara Grid.
1. INTRODUCTION
1
Changing and repurposing existing buildings for their
continued use, has become increasingly important. The
demolition and destruction of these buildings is not only
harmful to the environment but also harmful to the local
identity, cultural heritage and socio-economic values. In
the past decades, interventions in existing buildings to
preserve and sustain have become a creative challenge in
the field of 1 (Powell, 1999; Schittich, 2003). The
Adaptive Reuse of valuable buildings has been mentioned
Corresponding author: aeinifar@ut.ac.ir
*
© 2020 Iran University of Science & Technology. All rights reserved
in international heritage conservation policy documents
and charters as a recommended solution (ICOMOS, 2004;
Jessen & Schneider, 2003; J. Jokilehto, 2007; Machado,
1976). Moreover, this type of reuse has been studied in
related fields such as urban regeneration, engineering and
recycling, sustainability, economics, management … etc.
(Bullen & Love, 2010). Other terms such as
"Remodeling", "Retrofitting", "Conversion", "Adaptation",
"Reworking", "Rehabilitation" and "Refurbishment" have
been used in reference to the concept of Ada0259se
(Graeme Brooker & Stone, 2004; Giebeler et al., 2009;
Habibi & Maghsoudi, 2011; Machado, 1976).
Adaptive Reuse is not an emerging phenomenon. In the
Renaissance classical buildings were modified for new