XXX-X-XXXX-XXXX-X/XX/$XX.00 ©20XX IEEE
Tribological study of the stainless steel coating
multilayer for ball valves application
Khaled Chemaa
Department of mechanical engineering
Yahia Fares University
Medea, Algeria
Khaledchemaa@yahoo.com
Mohamed Kezrane
Department of mechanical engineering
Yahia Fares University
Medea, Algeria
mohamedkezrane@yahoo.fr
Salim Hassani
Center for development of advanced
technologies (CDTA)
MIL Division
Algiers, Algeria
shassani@cdta.dz
Abstract— Ball valves made by stainless steel alloys are
subjected to severe wear and corrosion during their services in
aggressive environments. The present study is aimed to study
the tribological behavior of stainless steel multilayer coating
with number of layers varied from 1 to 4 for future application
on ball valves. Surface roughness was reduced when increasing
the number of layers from 1 to 4. Tribological analysis showed
that both the coatings with 3 and 4 layers have the lowest
friction coefficients and that the coating with 4 layers present a
low wear.
Keywords— Stainless steel, Coatings, Tribology
I. INTRODUCTION
Ball valves presented in Fig.1 are widely used in oil and
gas industry in piping systems to control flowrates and flow
directions or to cut off the flow in pipelines [1].
Fig. 1. Ball valve
Generally, ball valves are made by stainless steel alloys
(mainly 304 and 316 alloys), unfortunately, stainless steel
alloys are featured with low wear resistance and hardness
which make them not fully suitable to resist at aggressive
environments without using some expensive coatings [2].
Figure 2 shows a ball valve with worn surface after just few
days of service.
Introducing a ball valve manufactured from carbon steel
alloy and coated with a wear resistant stainless steel coating
will offer an interesting transition in ball valves industry.
Due to their low processing cost, while presenting acceptable
oxides amount and low porosity [3], twin-wire arc spray
process can be considered as the most commercial used
thermal spray process [4].
The aim of the present work is to study the tribological
properties of stainless steel multilayers coatings on ball
valves made from carbon steel alloy with the variation of the
number of layers from one to four.
Fig. 2. Ball valve with a worn surface
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
EN 10025-2 carbon steel was used as substrate with 10
mm of diameter. The substrates were polished and grit
blasted with grease cast iron grits with 0.4 mm in diameter.
Commercial AISI 304L stainless steel wires with 1.6 mm in
diameters were used as feedstock. The nominal composition
of the 304L wire is: 0.08 wt% C, 2.00 wt% Mn, 0.030 wt%
S, 1.00 wt% Si, 0.045 wt% P, 8.00 wt% Ni, 18.00 wt% Cr
and balance of Fe. The stainless steel coatings were
produced by twin-wire arc spray system (Metallisation ltd,
UK) with an arc spray gun of Arcspray 234 type. The
spraying parameters are given in table 1.
The coatings phases’ analyses were carried out by X-
Ray diffraction (XRD, Bruker D8 Advance, Germany). The
coatings cross-sections were analyzed by Scanning Electron
Microscopy (SEM, FEI Quanta 650, USA).