2-D DOA Estimation of Coherent Wideband
Signals with Auxiliary-Vector Basis
Hovannes Kulhandjian
†
, Michel Kulhandjian
‡
, Youngwook Kim
†
and Claude D’Amours
‡
†
Department of Electrical Engineering, California State University, Fresno, CA 93740, USA
‡
School of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of Ottawa, Canada
E-mail: {hkulhandjian,youngkim}@csufresno.edu, mkk6@buffalo.edu, cdamours@uottawa.ca
Abstract—We develop a two-dimensional (2-D) direction-of-
arrival (DOA) estimation scheme for coherent wideband source
signals using coherent signal subspace method based auxiliary-
vector (CSSM-AV) basis. Computation of the basis is carried
out by a modified version of the orthogonal CSSM-AV filtering
algorithm. The proposed method reconstructs the signal subspace
using a cross-correlation matrix after which the modified CSSM-
AV algorithm is employed to estimate the azimuth and elevation
angles. Then, successive orthogonal maximum cross-correlation
auxiliary vectors are calculated to form a basis for the scanner-
extended signal subspace. This technique is very efficient in re-
ducing the algorithm complexity. Since it does not require that the
eigenvectors be determined in order to find the signal subspace
and yields a superior resolution performance for closely spaced
sources even when the number of samples is low. Specifically,
the complexity of the proposed 2-D DOA estimation algorithm
compared to the CSSM algorithm is more favorable when the
number of signals arriving on the antenna element is much less
than the number of antenna elements. Performance evaluation
shows that the proposed method outperforms competing methods
such as CSSM, TOPS and WAVES algorithms in terms of
estimation error, probability of resolution and number of sample
support for a given SNR in scenarios in which many sources are
present in the system, the array size is large, and the number of
samples is small.
Index Terms—Wideband direction-of-arrival (DOA) estima-
tion, uniform circular arrays (UCA), auxiliary-vector (AV) fil-
tering, small sample support.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Direction-of-arrival (DOA) estimation with sensor arrays
has been a central topic of signal processing research over
the past few decades due to its importance in radar, sonar, and
wireless communications [1], [2], [3]. DOA estimation tech-
niques can be classified into two main categories; maximum-
likelihood (ML) methods, which are based on the maximiza-
tion of the probability density function of the received signal
and signal subspace methods that are based on the eigen-
decomposition of the autocovariance matrix of the received
signal. Two of the well known subspace algorithms are mul-
tiple signal characterization (MUSIC) [4] and estimation of
signal parameters via rotational invariance technique (ESPRIT)
[5]. In general, ML-type algorithms have superior perfor-
mance compared to subspace-based techniques when either the
signal-to-noise (SNR) ratio or the sample size is small. Also,
in the case of correlated signal sources the performance of
subspace-based estimators degrades significantly, as compared
to ML schemes. The trade-off of ML-type algorithms com-
pared to subspace-based is the high computational complexity.
These DOA algorithms are primarily designed for narrow-
band signal sources and thus cannot be used for wideband
signals, as the phase difference between sensor outputs is
dependent on both the DOA and on the temporal frequency. A
number of wideband DOA estimation algorithms are proposed,
which are mainly based on coherent or noncoherent wideband
techniques. The incoherent signal subspace method (ISSM)
[6], [7] is one of the simplest wideband DOA estimation
method. In [7], the authors propose the ISSM for wideband
signals in which the received wideband signal is decomposed
into a set of narrowband signals on different frequency sub-
bands using the discrete Fourier transform (DFT), so that high-
resolution narrowband DOA estimators such as MUSIC can be
applied in each subband. In ISSM, each frequency subband
is processed independently and then the separate results are
averaged over all subbands. ISSM methods work well in
favorable situations, i.e., high SNR and well-separated signals.
Its performance may deteriorate with coherent sources or SNR
variations in different frequency subbands. An outlier in any
frequency subband could severely degrade the final estimate
due to the averaging process.
To overcome this problem a number of improved methods
have been proposed. Among those are the coherent signal sub-
space method (CSSM) [8]. In CSSM, the received wideband
signals are first decomposed into a set of narrowband signals
similar to ISSM. The covariance matrices of each subband
are transformed into covariance matrices of a certain focusing
frequency by multiplying them with focusing matrices. The
focusing matrices are used for the alignment of the signal
subspaces of narrowband components within the bandwidth
of the signals, followed by the averaging of narrowband co-
variance matrices into a universal covariance matrix. Then, any
narrowband DOA estimators such as MUSIC can be applied to
the universal covariance matrix to obtain the DOA estimates.
There are a number of different methods designed for focusing
matrices in the conventional CSSM. Although some of those
methods are simple to implement, they require initial DOA
estimates to calculate the focusing matrices. Therefore, the
final DOA estimates are very sensitive to the initial estimates.
The weighted average of signal subspace (WAVES) technique
[9] is a widely used method, which also requires the use of
978-1-5386-4328-0/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE