Prenuclear Low Tone Alignment in Dominican Spanish
Erik W. Willis
New Mexico State University
E-mail: erikw@nmsu.edu
ABSTRACT
Spanish prenuclear rising pitch accents have been
described as having a Low tone consistently aligned near
the onset of the tonic syllable and a High tone, whose
alignment may vary depending on focus marking. An
examination of Dominican Spanish (DS) reveals a
previously unreported alignment pattern for Spanish. The
DS data reveals a variable Low tone alignment; an early
alignment near the tonic onset, and a late Low alignment,
past the tonic midpoint, typically 100-180 ms into the tonic
syllable. The High tone does not demonstrate two
categories of alignment seen with the Low tone. The
variation observed in the DS prenuclear pitch accent
alignments provide clear evidence of intonational dialectal
variation and contributes to the growing body of research
on intonational variation in general.
1. INTRODUCTION
Pitch accent tonal alignment refers to the location of a
valley or tonal peak with respect to a syllable boundary.
Researchers in many languages have noted and described
contrastive pitch accents based on the tonal alignment of
the F0 contour with the lexically stressed syllable.
Most previous reports of Low tone alignment of prenuclear
rising pitch accents in Spanish note a Low tone that occurs
near the onset of the tonic syllable (see Figure 1a) [2, 3, 4, 5,
8, 9, 11, 13, 17]. There are only two reports of a Spanish
prenuclear rising pitch accent with a Low tone that occurs
late in the tonic syllable; both reports were for Caribbean
dialects of Spanish [2, 15].
Figure 1: Schematic of rising pitch accents in
Peninsular Spanish.
Previous reports of Spanish contrastive focus in prenuclear
pitch accents find that the Low tone is likewise consistently
aligned near the onset of the tonic syllable, and that the
alignment of the High tone realized within the tonic
syllable serves to indicate contrastive focus [3, 4, 5, 8, 13].
Based on these findings, it has been assumed that there are
two Spanish prenuclear rising pitch accents which were
distinguished by the alignment of the High tone (see Figure
1).
Only recently has tonal alignment been applied to dialectal
studies with positive results. It has been reported that
different dialects of English resolve tonal clash
environments differently [7]. Serbian and Croatian
dialects have been distinguished based on tonal alignment
in response to specific focus conditions [14]. The Belgrade
dialect with a contrastive lexical pitch accent shows a
relatively consistent tonal alignment despite variations of
focus conditions (broad and narrow focus). However, the
Zagreb dialect, which has lost the lexical pitch accent
distinction between rising and falling tones, demonstrates a
significant modification of tonal alignment under broad and
narrow focus conditions [14]. Recently, it has been
reported that there are small but significant differences in
tonal alignment of Northern and Southern German speakers
[1]. Finally, two Pisa Italian dialects have been
differentiated based on the alignments of specific tones [6].
This paper examines the tonal alignment of prenuclear
rising pitch accents in Dominican Spanish (DS) spoken in
Santiago de los Caballeros, in the “Cibao” region of the
country of the Dominican Republic. The findings indicate
that there are two distinct alignments for the prenuclear
Low tone in DS.
2. PROCEDURE
The data for the current study is based on a corpus of
declaratives produced with broad focus and contrastive
focus by four female speakers of DS (a total of 288
declarative utterances). The speakers were all volunteers
and students of the Pontificia Universidad Católica Madre
y Maestra (PUCCM). In all cases, the speakers were
volunteers and were naive as to the purpose of the study.
The informants for the experimental data all fit a particular
sociolinguistic characterization determined from a brief
biographical survey conducted prior to the experiment,
which is necessary when addressing dialectal variation.
The experimental corpus findings are corroborated by data
from spontaneous speech conversations by additional
speakers.
15th ICPhS Barcelona
2941 ISBN 1-876346-48-5 © 2003 UAB