VOL. 10, NO. 15, AUGUST 2015 ISSN 1819-6608
ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences
© 2006-2015 Asian Research Publishing Network (ARPN). All rights reserved.
www.arpnjournals.com
6230
A REVIEW ON BREAST ELECTRICAL IMPEDANCE TOMOGRAPHY
CLINICAL ACCURACY
Zain N. M.
1
and Kanaga K. C.
2
1
School of Medical Imaging, Faculty of Health Sciences, KPJ Healthcare University College, Nilai, Malaysia
2
Faculty of Health Sciences, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), Jalan Raja Muda Abdul Aziz, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
E-Mail: norhayati@kpjuc.edu.my
ABSTRACT
Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a non-invasive procedure using electrical impedance to image the
human breast. Due to its mobility and using non-compression technique it is appealing to patients. This scanning device
does not emit any ionizing radiation thus it can be done on pregnant women by means of no age limit. Since the EIT has
play some supplementary function in the breast imaging, a lot of research on its clinical accuracy has been done. Therefore,
the aim is to carry out a review of EIT clinical accuracy and assess the quality of journal by using Quality Assessment of
Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS) criteria. The journals that assess the sensitivity were search through various
databases and the clinical accuracy of EIT in each journal is recorded. The review shows that the range sensitivity (Sn) of
EIT system to human breast in ten journals was between 17% and 94.6%. The range of specificity (Sp) is between 49% and
97.1%. The negative (NPV) and positive predictive value (PPV) is between 74% and 98%; 4% and 73.3% respectively.
The accuracy (ACC) of EIT is between 69% and 80.5%. This value is found to be supported that EIT can be used as an
adjunct screening technique for human breast.
Keywords: electrical impedance tomography, diagnostic accuracy, breast cancer.
INTRODUCTION
Breast cancer is considered to be the final
outcome of multiple environmental and hereditary factors
and therefore the best way to prevent mortality is by early
detection. Nowadays, there are various modalities for
diagnostic imaging such as magnetic resonance imaging
(MRI), computed tomography (CT) scan and
mammography. Between all the modalities,
mammography has become a gold standard for breast
imaging (Tinberg et al. 2011). Mammography has become
an effective imaging tool for detecting early stage of
carcinomas in the breast (Park et al. 2007). However it
uses ionizing radiation and causes discomfort to patients
due to compression of the breast tissues (Prasad et al.,
2008). Attenuation of the tissues using radiation enables
the inner structure of breast tissues to be visualized on the
mammogram tissues (Zou and Guo, 2003). Other
modalities namely ultrasound is used as an adjunct to
mammography for the differentiation of potentially
suspicious breast lesions (Subbhuraam et al. 2011).
Breast imaging together with other more
advanced complementary methods focuses on improving
early detection of the cancer cells and reduces the
occurrence of missed cancers (Houssami et al. 2009). One
suggested method is electrical impedance tomography
(EIT). A potentially, new noninvasive diagnostic
technique based on different electrical storage potential of
normal and pathologically altered tissues allowing image
differences in the tissue conductivity and permittivity
inferred from the body surface electrical measurements.
EIT consists of a hand-held scanning probe and a
computer screen that displays two-dimensional images of
the breast. The EIT examination is performed with the
subject recumbent, with both arms raised above the head.
The purpose of this position is to flatten the breast as much
as possible, allowing optimal contact of the flat surface of
the scan probe with the breast tissue. The transducer is
firmly pressed against the breast and the probe is moved in
such a way as to remove air bubbles and to ensure good
contact with the breast. Due to its mobility and utilizing a
non-compression technique it is appealing to patients. This
scanning device does not emit any ionizing radiation thus
it can be done on pregnant women by resulting in no age
limit (Abdi and Liatsis, 2011).
The aim of this review is to systematically collect
journals on the clinical accuracy of breast EIT in detecting
breast cancer. The journals then will be evaluated
according to the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic
Accuracy Studies (QUADAS) criteria.
METHODOLOGY
The literature search for relevant references was
performed by using two different databases, which
included Medline and Scopus to cover publications
between 2000 and 2015. Archived journal are assessed
through the University Kebangsaan Malaysia library
database and were extracted based on the criteria
mentioned bellow. The terms used for identification of
references were ‘electrical impedance tomography’;
‘breast cancer’; and ‘sensitivity’. The search was limited
to include all the studies that had been published in the
English language and related to the clinical accuracy of
EIT specifically on human breast tissue. Exclusion criteria
included experimental studies, studies that did not
highlight details on sensitivity (Sn) on overall performance
of breast EIT and any review studies. Additionally those
which full text could not be obtained were excluded.
Comparisons of the sensitivity in each journal were
performed based on overall performance.