The 7
th
International Conference for Informatics and Information Technology (CIIT 2010)
©2010 Institute of Informatics.
ANALYSIS OF VOICE OVER IP DURING VERTICAL HANDOVERS IN
HETEROGENEOUS WIRELESS AND MOBILE NETWORKS
Kire Jakimoski Toni Janevski
Ss. Cyril and Methodius University,
Faculty of Electrical Engineering
and Information Technologies
Ss. Cyril and Methodius University,
Faculty of Electrical Engineering
and Information Technologies
Skopje, Republic of Macedonia Skopje, Republic of Macedonia
ABSTRACT
Roaming across different heterogeneous technologies such as
802.11, WiMAX and UMTS will become a requirement of
future networking devices, especially for Voice over IP
traffic, which nowadays is one of the most important services
regarding the performance evaluation of wireline and wireless
networks.
In this paper we perform a study on the performance of voice
packet transmissions during vertical handovers between 3G-
HSPA, WiMAX (IEEE 802.16) and WLAN (IEEE 802.11)
wireless networks. In particular, we analyze the performance
metrics, such as handover latency and packet loss, for
obtaining the effects of vertical handover on the mobile node
performance, by using the recommended parameter values for
link triggers and router configuration in IEEE 802.21
standard.
Results show that the handover latency is severely impacted
by the choice of the time interval parameters on the link layer,
especially in the case of UMTS to WiMAX vertical handover.
Packet loss is also analyzed in order to have the best
optimization in vertical handovers between UMTS, WiMAX
and WLAN, for Voice over IP traffic.
I. INTRODUCTION
Next-generation wireless networks have been envisioned as
an IP-based infrastructure with the integration of various
wireless access networks such as IEEE 802.11 wireless local
area networks (WLANs), IEEE 802.16 wireless metropolitan
area networks (WMANs), and Universal Mobile
Telecommunications System (UMTS). Heterogeneous
wireless networks need to cooperate to provide users with
seamless mobility and required quality of service (QoS).
Mobile nodes can automatically switch the connectivity
between different types of networks.
The vertical handover occurs when the connection to a mobile
user changes from one network to the other during a call. The
process of deciding and executing a vertical handover is more
complex than a horizontal handover with a network such as
the case that a mobile user switches its home base station.
IEEE 802.21 [1] defines a media-independent handover
(MIH) framework that can significantly improve handover
between heterogeneous network technologies. The standard
defines the tools required to exchange information, events,
and commands to facilitate handover initiation and handover
preparation. IEEE 802.21 does not attempt to standardize the
actual handover execution mechanism. Therefore, the MIH
framework is equally applicable to systems that employ
mobile IP at the IP layer as to systems that employ Session
Initiation Protocol (SIP) at the application layer.
On the other hand, in the recent past, there has been a
tremendous increase in the popularity of VoIP services as a
result of huge growth in broadband access. The same VoIP
service poses new challenges when deployed over a
heterogeneous wireless network while enabling users to make
voice calls during vertical handovers using mobile nodes with
different interfaces.
In this paper, through an extensive simulation study, the
effect of DCD/UCD interval (WiMAX MAC layer parameter)
on vertical handover performance for VoIP traffic according
IEEE 802.21 standard has been investigated. In the simulation
environment, terminals move according to the different
random trajectories. Performance of vertical handovers is
measured based on vertical handover latency and packet loss.
According to the 802.21 standard, the handover algorithm
configures the power thresholds, and then handovers are
triggered by signals received from lower layers. We analyze
the effect of the DCD/UCD interval on vertical handover
latency and packet loss between UMTS/WiMAX/WLAN
networks. The results indicate that the choice of DCD/UCD
interval has great impact on the VoIP QoS during vertical
handover between UMTS and WiMAX with the IEEE 802.21
specification.
This paper is organized as follows: Section II is the
introduction to the VoIP and G.723.1 codec used in the
simulations. Section III shows the simulation scenario.
Simulation model, simulation parameters and handover
performance metrics are explained in details. Section IV gives
the results and analysis from the simulations and finally
Section V concludes this paper.
II. VOIP TRAFFIC
In the context of IP networks, telephony services are known
as Voice over IP (VoIP). A VoIP flow depending on the
encoding employed, such as G.711, G.723.1 or G.729, can
generate data rates between 5.33 and 64 Kbps. Packets are
generated isochronously at the supported packetization rate
through the real time protocol (RTP) containing a fixed size
payload.
To maintain a conversation at good quality levels, a VoIP
flow requires low packet loss rates. Loss rates up to 10% may
be tolerated depending on the type of packet concealment
technique employed by the decoder on the side of the
receiver. To sustain intelligibility of VoIP communications
the total end-to-end delay should remain below 150 ms or
lower, for highly interactive conversations. Delays in the
range of 150-400 ms are considered acceptable, although the