RESEARCH ARTICLE
New insights into René Magritte's early surrealist painting
La salle d'armes
Catherine Defeyt
1,2
| Francisca Vandepitte
2
| Elodie Herens
1
| David Strivay
1
1
Centre Européen d'Archéométrie, UR
Art, Archéologie, Patrimoine,
Universitéde Liège, Liège, Belgium
2
Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium,
Brussels, Belgium
Correspondence
Catherine Defeyt, Centre Européen
d'Archéométrie, UR AAP, Sart Tilman
B15, Université de Liège, B-4000 Liège,
Belgium.
Email: catherine.defeyt@uliege.be
Funding information
Belgian Federal Science Policy Office,
Grant/Award Number: FED-
tWIN2019-prf060
Painted in 1925 or 1926, over an older composition, La salle d'armes, is among
the first Magritte's surrealist paintings. It is also one of the only four Magritte's
using enamels reported in the René Magritte Catalog Raisonné. This paper
presents the material and technical study conducted on this double painting.
The complementary imaging and analytical methods applied for this purpose
provided substantial information on both, the visible image and the hidden
one. Concerning the latter, for instance, the obtained results permitted to iden-
tify a cubo-futurist oil painting from the very early 1920s.
KEYWORDS
double painting, enamels, MA-XRF, pigments, René Magritte
1 | INTRODUCTION
After a cubo-futuristic period in the early 1920s, René
Magritte began to develop a more personal and poetic
imagery. Numerous novel items that will later become
emblematic of Magritte's surrealism, including stereo-
graphic double portraits, red curtains, bilboquets, and
heads without body, were first introduced in composi-
tions dating from 1925 or 1926.
Painted in 1925 or 1926, La salle d'armes (Figure 1) is
considered as one of the earliest Magritte's surrealist
paintings
[1]
. The plaster head, appearing for the first
time here, will give rise to iconic surrealist paintings,
such as L'homme célèbre, Le Visage du Génie, Le Mariage
de minuit and La Forêt, all executed between 1926 and
1927. In the same way, the table, displayed in La salle
d'armes will be included in several paintings made after-
ward, that is L'oasis, La traversée difficile, La naissance de
l'idole, and Le marriage de minuit, all dated 1926.
In addition, La salle d'armes shows typical signs of re-
used painting substrates, chiefly reliefs of underlying pat-
terns without connection with the current image
(Figure 2). The current composition has been well exe-
cuted over a former picture, painted itself on a recycled
burlap bag. In view of that, La salle d'armes does not only
crystallize the early stages of Magritte's surrealism; it also
testifies of the material insecurity the painter had to face
during his early career. Indeed, David Sylvester has
pointed out the relationship between Magritte's financial
difficulties persisting until the late 1940s and the fact the
painter had routinely recycled the canvas supports from
older paintings, this until at least 1935.
1
La salle d'armes
presents an additional technical specificity; it is one of
the only four Magritte's paintings that involve enamel
paints.
2
Therefore, the material and technical study of this
singular work, formerly belonging to the Max Janlet col-
lection,
3
seemed to be of considerable interest and must
be undertaken. That is why La salle d'armes, which was
housed by the Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium
(RMFAB) for a long time, has been investigated in the
framework of the research project Magritte on practice
(2015–2018) consisting on the in situ investigation of
50 oil paintings and 10 gouaches made by the artist
between 1920 and 1967, and housed by the Magritte
Museum (RMFAB).
This paper presents the outcomes achieved in regard
with the style, the subject, the date, and the palette of the
Received: 29 April 2020 Revised: 20 November 2021 Accepted: 23 November 2021
DOI: 10.1002/xrs.3277
X-Ray Spectrom. 2021;1–7. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/xrs © 2021 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. 1