Fast Optimal Multimodal Thresholding Based on Between-Class Variance
Using a Mixture of Gamma Distributions
Eidah Assidan and Ali El-Zaart
Department of Computer Science
College of Computer and Information Sciences
King Saud University
eidah7@hotmail.com , dr_elzaart@yahoo.com , and elzaart@ksu.edu.sa
Abstract
Images segmentation is an important issue for many
applications as pattern recognition and computer
vision. Thresholding is an important and fast technique
used in most applications. Gaussian Otsu’s method is a
thresholding technique based on between class
variance. Gamma distribution models data more than
Gaussian distribution. In this paper, we developed a
new formula using Otsu’s method for estimating the
optimal threshold values based on Gamma
distribution. Our method applied on bimodal and
multimodal images. Also It uses an iteratively rather
than sequentially to decrease the number of
operations. Further, using Gamma distribution give
satisfying thresholding results in low-high contrast
images where modes are symmetric or non-symmetric.
For our results, we compared it with the original
Gaussian Otsu’s method.
Keywords: Gamma distribution, Thresholding,
Between-Class Variance.
1. Introduction
Image segmentation is an important issue in many
image-processing applications for separating objects of
interest and displaying them obviously. Many
segmentation methods have been proposed and applied
in many different applications [1, 2, 3, 4]. In
thresholding techniques only, there are more than 40
thresholding methods [5]. However, many studies
focus on thresholding techniques for segmentation.
Thresholding based on between-class variance (BCV)
separates the object from the background in most
images. As well as many studies were invented to
improve BCV methods [13, 8]. In [14] the obtaining
threshold value is based in Genetic Algorithm (GA) by
finding out the valley bottom between two peaks in the
histogram of image. Also, paper [15] discusses the
impact of class probability and class variance to find
the threshold value. However, all these studies are
based on Gaussian distribution to find the threshold
value, which gives limited results restricted by
symmetric modes. Our contribution in this paper is to
improve the Otsu’s method [6, 7] in the case of non-
symmetrical histogram by using Gamma distribution.
We applied our method for estimating the optimal
threshold values on bimodal and multimodal images.
In addition, using iteratively algorithm rather than
sequential.
A similar study was an improvement in minimum
cross entropy thresholding (MCET) method by using
Gamma distribution [10, 12]. It is shows that used
Gamma distribution to improve both bimodal and
multimodal thresholding methods give good results
which encourage us to use Gamma distribution to
improve another method (Otsu’s method) and develop
our method. Furthermore, Gamma distribution has the
ability to deal with low-high contrast images where
modes (intensity value distribution in the histogram)
are symmetric or non-symmetric. While Gaussian
distribution that has been used in old Otsu’s method is
suitable more for symmetric mode, but it gives limited
results in non-symmetric mode.
This paper is organized as follows: Section 2
describes Gamma distribution concept. In section 3, we
present our new formula to find the optimal threshold
value on bimodal and multimodal images. Section 4
provides experimental results of the new formula on
bimodal and multimodal images. Finally, conclusion
and future work is presented in section 5.
2. Gamma Distribution
Histogram represents statistical information of
image pixels. It describes pixels intensity distribution
in an image by graphing the number of pixels intensity
Proceedings of the 2009 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics
San Antonio, TX, USA - October 2009
978-1-4244-2794-9/09/$25.00 ©2009 IEEE
2673