Vol. 68, Nr. 2, 2003—JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE 503 © 2003 Institute of Food Technologists
Further reproduction prohibited without permission
Food Engineering and Physical Properties
Dependence of Coating Thickness on
Viscosity of Coating Solution Applied to
Fruits and Vegetables by Dipping Method
L. CISNEROS-ZEVALLOS AND J.M. KROCHTA
ABSTRACT: Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose solutions were used as coating systems in this study and solution concen-
trations, viscosity, densities, and surface tensions were characterized. Fuji apples were coated by dipping and stored 4
d at room temperature, after which the internal oxygen and carbon dioxide were measured. Results indicated that
coating thickness varied with viscosity, concentration, density, and draining time of the biopolymer solution. Coating
thickness relates to the square root of viscosity and the inverse square root of draining time, which agrees with the
theoretical approach for flat plate dip-coating in low-capillary-number Newtonian liquids. These results indicate the
possibility of controlling coating thickness and internal gas composition based on coating solution properties.
Keywords: coating thickness, viscosity, fruits, vegetables, modified atmosphere
Introduction
T
HE USE OF BIOPOLYMER COATINGS TO MODIFY INTERNAL ATMO-
spheres of fruits and vegetables has been studied extensively
during the past 20 y. However, research in this area has been mostly
empirical, providing unpredictable results and diverse conclusions.
Internal atmosphere modification seems to depend on elements
such as coating permeability, thickness and surface coverage by the
film. However, little is known of the factors that may influence these
elements. Thus, we believe that knowledge of the physical–chemical
properties of the coating solutions and coating interactions with the
surface of different commodities will allow a more predictable coat-
ing performance (Cisneros-Zevallos and others 1994a).
Film thickness is considered to influence coating response by
defining the distance through which the gas permeant has to dif-
fuse (Ben-Yehoshua 1967; Meheriuk and Lau 1988; Hagenmeier
and Shaw 1992; Hagenmeier and Baker 1994; Park and others
1994a). The internal gas modification in coated fruits has been in-
directly related to coating thickness through coating gas resistance
parameters (Trout and others 1953; Banks and others 1993; Hagen-
meier and Baker 1993), and through the solid concentration of coat-
ing solutions (Park and others 1994a, 1994b).
Studies on plate dip-coating have shown that the thickness
of deposited liquid film coatings depends on the coating solu-
tion properties such as density, viscosity and surface tension,
as well as surface withdrawal speed from the coating solution.
Different theoretical approaches have been used to estimate the
film thickness from these properties (Levich 1962; Groenveld
1970; Scriven 1988; Derjaguin 1993). It has been reported that
thickness, h, relates to withdrawal speed, U, by h ~ U
1/2
; and
under certain conditions h ~ U
2/3
. For viscosity, , the relation
is h~
1/2
or h~
2/3
.
The following equations have been proposed to describe the
thickness of coatings:
h = 0.944Ca
1/6
(U/g)
1/2
(1)
and
h = K(U/g)
1/2
(2)
Eq. 1, proposed by Landau and Levich (1942), is used in the case
where thickness is defined by a 3-sided force competition between
the viscosity, surface tension and gravity. Eq. 1 holds for low capil-
lary numbers (Ca < 10
–3
). Eq. 2 defines thickness as a competition
between viscous and gravity forces, with surface tension forces
being overshadowed by the first 2. Eq. 2 was derived by solving the
flow equation for a liquid film of constant thickness, in the case of
Newtonian fluids where the capillary number is <10
-3
. However, it
has also been used for high capillary numbers (Ca > 1). In both cas-
es, the proportionality constant K can be experimentally deter-
mined (Groenveld 1970; Scriven 1988; Guglielmi and Zenezini
1990; Guglielmi and others 1992).
The same approach can be applied to problems of liquid coat-
ing plate withdrawal and drainage. A plate that is pulled out of the
bath in a very short time and then left to drain is considered a drain-
ing plate. The transformation of withdrawal speed (U) to draining
time is given as (Groenveld 1970; Toledo 1991):
U = z/t (3)
The objective of our study was to apply the physical principles
of the dip coating process to apple fruits and to define the relation-
ship between the coating thickness, the properties of coating solu-
tion and the internal gas modification of fruits.
Material and Methods
Fruit material
Fuji apples used in this study were harvested at commercial
maturity stage from the experimental orchard of the Pomology
Dept., Univ. California, Davis (Davis, Calif., U.S.A.). All fruits were
carefully hand harvested leaving stems attached to the fruit and
avoiding touching the surface, then stored at 2.5 °C until use.
Coating solutions
Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) (Methocel, Dow Chem-
ical Co., Midland, Mich., U.S.A.) aqueous solutions were used for
JFS: Food Engineering and Physical Properties