57 © Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2019
E. S.-y. Chan, T. Matsuda (eds.), Endourology Progress, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-3465-8_8
Multiple vs. Single Access PCNL
Michael Alfred V. Tan and Dennis G. Lusaya
Abstract
Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) is the standard of
care for large renal calculi which are no longer suitable
for extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy. The key to suc-
cess depends on the urologist’s choice of instruments,
preoperative and intraoperative access planning, patience,
perseverance, skill and training. Percutaneous renal
access is a crucial early step that may ultimately infuence
outcomes of PCNL in terms of overall stone-free rate and
complications. Several techniques for access and tract
dilatation are described in this chapter. Prone, supine or
lateral positioning during renal access have inherent
advantages and disadvantages. Similarly, various adjunct
imaging modalities and instrumentation are available to
increase success and decrease the risk of complications.
Nonetheless, the most practical and effective approach
still depends heavily on stone burden and renal anatomy,
available instrumentation and equipment, and the sur-
geon’s expertise and level of training.
Keywords
Percutaneous nephrolithotomy · PCNL · Stone
The 2005 American Urological Association guidelines on
the management of staghorn calculi has recommended per-
cutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) for treatment of renal
calculi 2 cm and larger. Success of a PCNL procedure
depends on several factors which include: preoperative plan-
ning, the correct choice of puncture site and access tech-
nique, and effcacy of tract dilatation, nephroscopy, stone
fragmentation, extraction and drainage. Planning of tract
placement could never be overemphasized. Meticulous eval-
uation of preoperative imaging will dictate the choice of
access site and the intrarenal endoscopic route that would
yield high stone free rates with minimal morbidity. Access to
the kidney is arguably the most crucial step in PCNL as the
site of entry will determine the approach and equipment
needed for stone clearance. If done properly, it can maximize
the effciency of rigid and fexible instruments, minimize
morbidity and allow for execution of adjunctive procedures.
8.1 Positioning the Patient
Fluoroscopy-guided percutaneous access requires opacifca-
tion of the renal collecting system. This is achieved by inject-
ing radiographic contrast medium through a ureteral catheter
with one end externalized through the urethra. This can be
easily performed using rigid instruments with the patient in a
dorsal lithotomy position. In certain instances, fexible cys-
toscopy with the patient supine or prone may also be done
for ureteral catheter placement and retrograde pyelography.
Following ureteral catheter placement, a Foley catheter is
also routinely placed. The exposed caudal segment of the
ureteral catheter is secured to the Foley catheter to prevent
misplacement of the cephalic segment inside the collecting
system as the patient is re-positioned and re-draped for per-
cutaneous access.
The patient can be positioned either prone, supine or lat-
erally (with further variations such as split-leg, slightly
oblique, etc.) for percutaneous renal access depending on the
preference of the surgeon. The prone position offers direct
and shorter access to the collecting system with minimal
interference from other intraabdominal organs. It also poten-
tially exposes multiple calyces for easier percutaneous
access. These may be circumvented in supine and lateral
M. A. V. Tan (*)
University of Santo Tomas Hospital, Manila, Philippines
D. G. Lusaya
Department of Surgery, Faculty of Medicine and Surgery,
University of Santo Tomas, Manila, Philippines
Department of Urology, Faculty of Medicine and Surgery,
University of Santo Tomas, Manila, Philippines
St. Luke’s Medical Center Institute of Urology,
Quezon City, Philippines
8