Separation and Purification Technology 73 (2010) 13–19
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Separation and Purification Technology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/seppur
Molecular dynamics simulation of the complex dopant effect on the super-ionic
conduction and microstructure of zirconia-based solid electrolytes
Kuo-Lun Tung
∗
, Kai-Shiun Chang, Chi-Chung Hsiung, Yen-Cheng Chiang, Yu-Ling Li
R&D Center of Membrane Technology and Department of Chemical Engineering, Chung Yuan Christian University, Chung-Li, Taoyuan 320, Taiwan
article info
Keywords:
SOFC
Solid electrolyte
Ionic conductivity
Molecular dynamics
MSD
abstract
The complex dopant effect on the super-ionic conduction and structural stability of zirconia-based solid
electrolyte for solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) applications was investigated using the molecular dynamics
(MD) technique. Various components of Sc
2
O
3(x)
–Y
2
O
3(1-x)
were added to the cubic zirconia cell to build
a scandia–yttria-stabilized zirconia (Sc–Y–SZ) model. The oxygen ion diffusion mechanism and ionic
conductivity obtained by MD simulation were examined to gain insight into how the performance was
improved by adding different Sc
2
O
3
concentrations. The radial distribution function (RDF) of the O–O
pair was determined to analyze the oxygen ion mobility using microstructure analysis. The mean-square
displacement (MSD) of the cations and RDF of the Zr–Zr pair were investigated to determine how the
structural stability was affected by the concentration of doped Sc
2
O
3
. The simulated results were in
agreement with the experimental data reported in the literature, suggesting that MD simulation is a
feasible technique for use in the material design and development of SOFC applications.
© 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Zirconia-based solid electrolyte doped with 8–10 mol% dopant
is regarded as an effective ionic transport medium for high perfor-
mance solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) applications [1]. However, the
reduced ionic conductivity at the decreased operation temperature
and various limitations in the high temperature region constrain
the development of the SOFCs technology [2,3]. Therefore, it is
desirable to improve the performance of the solid electrolytes in
the intermediate-temperature range for commercial applications.
To optimize the trade-off between performance and durability,
many studies attempted to dope with a multi-component additive
to improve the ionic conductivity at intermediate temperatures
[2–6]. For instance, the effect of yttria doped in the Sc
2
O
3
–ZrO
2
system on cubic fluorite structure stability and the effect of scan-
dia doped in the Y
2
O
3
–ZrO
2
system on ionic conductivity have
been discussed [7]. In the Sc
2
O
3
-rich Sc–Y–SZ system, the ionic
conductivity showed obvious deterioration at 1000
◦
C due to the
tetrahedron phase transformed from the cubic phase that was unfa-
vorable for ion diffusion [8,9]. Moreover, the addition of BiO
2
in the
ScSZ system may also help inhibit the phase transformation from
cubic to rhombohedral by reducing the sintering temperature to
maintain the structural stability [10]. The zirconia-based solid elec-
trolyte with excellent ionic conductivity reached 0.16–0.18 S/cm at
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +886 3 2654129; fax: +886 3 2654199.
E-mail address: kuolun@cycu.edu.tw (K.-L. Tung).
1273 K and was also successfully formed by doped complex dopant
[3,4]. Hence, the doping of the electrolytes with complex additives
is a superior way to develop super-conducted solid electrolytes at
intermediate temperatures.
However, the mechanism underlying the enhancement of ionic
conductivity in the solid electrolyte upon doping the complex
dopant was not fully understood. Insight at the molecular level
to reveal the microstructure of complex dopant doped solid elec-
trolyte and its performance of ionic conduction would be helpful for
further in-depth study. In the past decade, it was discovered that
molecular dynamics (MD) simulation is a feasible tool for micro-
scale analyses [11–16]. Sawaguchi and Ogawa [12] found that the
thermal motion of oxygen ions was mainly attributed to the “jump
motion” at high working temperatures. The increased activation
energy resulting from dopant addition was considered to be the
major barrier for ionic conduction. Kilo et al. [13] compared the dif-
fusion coefficient of oxygen ions inside the YSZ structure obtained
from simulated and experimental work. The radial distribution
function (RDF) of O–O, O–Zr and O–Y pairs was used to analyze the
ion mobility in the YSZ structure. Devanathan et al. [14] analyzed
the favored positions of oxygen vacancies inside the YSZ structure
using the analysis of the coordination number of Zr
+4
and Y
+3
near
the oxygen ions. The formation of a neutral Y
′
Zr
–V
O
••
–Y
′
Zr
cluster
might be an important reason for the conductivity degradation of
YSZ. Chen et al. [15] analyzed the interaction between neighboring
oxygen ions using a density functional method to investigate the
stability of a single and mixed doped cubic-ZrO
2
system. Ogawa
et al. [16] discussed the high temperature deformation of ceram-
1383-5866/$ – see front matter © 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.seppur.2009.07.026