Early warning of changing drinking water quality by trend
analysis
Jani Tomperi, Esko Juuso and Kauko Leiviskä
ABSTRACT
Monitoring and control of water treatment plants play an essential role in ensuring high quality
drinking water and avoiding health-related problems or economic losses. The most common quality
variables, which can be used also for assessing the efficiency of the water treatment process, are
turbidity and residual levels of coagulation and disinfection chemicals. In the present study, the trend
indices are developed from scaled measurements to detect warning signs of changes in the quality
variables of drinking water and some operating condition variables that strongly affect water quality.
The scaling is based on monotonically increasing nonlinear functions, which are generated with
generalized norms and moments. Triangular episodes are classified with the trend index and its
derivative. Deviation indices are used to assess the severity of situations. The study shows the
potential of the described trend analysis as a predictive monitoring tool, as it provides an advantage
over the traditional manual inspection of variables by detecting changes in water quality and giving
early warnings.
Jani Tomperi (corresponding author)
Esko Juuso
Kauko Leiviskä
Control Engineering, Faculty of Technology,
University of Oulu,
PO Box 4300, FIN-90014 University of Oulu,
Oulu,
Finland
E-mail: jani.tomperi@oulu.fi
Key words | aluminium, drinking water, nonlinear scaling, operating conditions, turbidity,
water treatment process
INTRODUCTION
There is a growing demand to improve water treatment man-
agement to ensure high quality water for consumers at as
low as possible operating cost. Efficient monitoring and con-
trol have a key role in high quality drinking water processing
at water treatment plants (WTPs). Many process measure-
ments are available in modern WTPs, but the quality of
the processed water is not measured until it is leaving the
plant for distribution to consumers and corrective control
actions have no effect on water quality. In addition, water
treatment processes are very challenging for monitoring,
modelling and control because they are complex, nonlinear
processes where several (partly unknown) variables affect
the functionality and quality of water. Poorly operating
WTPs and low quality water may cause health problems to
consumers and significant economic losses to a WTP.
Health effects can be due to single exposures to microbial
pathogens or long-term exposure to chemicals. Economic
losses include excessive chemical and energy consumption,
cleaning the distribution system, compensation to consu-
mers and process improvements. The contamination of the
water can be prevented, reduced or eliminated by the
proper control of the process. Successful control, on the
other hand, requires accurate monitoring of the process.
Specific limits of the operating and quality variables are
monitored by on-line or laboratory analysis (WHO (World
Health Organization) , ).
The quality of drinking water and the efficiency of a
WTP can be assessed by many parameters, but the most
common are turbidity and residual chemical level. Surface
waters are typically treated by a chemical coagulation-
based process, and aluminium or iron salts are widely
used as coagulants to reduce the organic matter, colour
and turbidity of raw water (WHO (World Health Organiz-
ation) ). Aluminium has a good ability to coagulate
433 © IWA Publishing 2016 Journal of Water and Health | 14.3 | 2016
doi: 10.2166/wh.2016.330
Downloaded from https://iwaponline.com/jwh/article-pdf/14/3/433/394303/jwh0140433.pdf
by guest
on 21 December 2018