2004-01-2509
Characteristics of an Open Loop Pulsating Heat Pipe
Roger R. Riehl
National Institute for Space Research – INPE/DMC/Satelite
Copyright © 2004 SAE International
ABSTRACT
This paper presents an experimental investigation of an
open loop pulsating heat pipe (OLPHP), where several
issues related to its performance were evaluated. Tests
were conducted with different working fluids for the
OLPHP operating at both vertical and horizontal
orientations. The experimental results show that the
system presented better performance when operating at
horizontal orientation, as lower evaporation section
temperatures were achieved. Regarding the working
fluids used, the system showed better performance when
acetone was used on vertical orientation and methanol
on horizontal orientation.
INTRODUCTION
Pulsating heat pipes (PHPs) are passive two-phase
thermal control devices first introduced by Akachi et al.
[1]. Mainly, PHPs consist of a capillary tube bent in
several curves to form parallel passages. In this
application, reduced diameter channels are used, which
are directly influenced by the selected working fluid. The
vapor plugs generated by the evaporation of the working
fluid push the liquid slugs toward the condensation
section and this motion causes flow oscillations that
guide the device operation [2]. There are several
applications for PHPs, from electronics and structural
thermal control as well as microgravity thermal control.
Due to the simple construction, light weight and low cost,
PHPs have gained attention to be used in space
radiators, in order to give a more isothermal
characteristic for this component. Integrating such a
device does not represent a major issue and it could be
easily used in several other applications.
There are two possible configurations for PHPs, being as
an open loop and as a closed loop. In the open loop
configuration, one end of the tube is pinched off and
welded, while the other end may present a service valve
for evacuation and charging. The closed loop
configuration has both ends connected and the fluid is
allowed to circulate. Issues related to the design and
operation of PHPs are still under investigation and this
subject still represents an open field to be explored.
Considering the sections of a PHP, it presents an
evaporation and a condensation section and may also
present an adiabatic section. The tube does not present
a wick structure and its construction is very simple. As
any other two-phase passive thermal control device, heat
is acquired from the source through the evaporation
section transferring it to the working fluid where the
slug/plug pumping action will be generated. The fluid
then flows by the adiabatic section towards the
condensation section. On a closed loop configuration,
the fluid is allowed to circulate and after being
condensed, the fluid returns to the evaporation section to
complete the loop. On the open loop configuration, the
liquid circulation is not possible. In this case, it is
believed that a counter-current liquid/vapor flow occurs in
order to promote the proper device operation [3].
Therefore, better understanding on this behavior is still a
motivation for further investigations.
Previous investigations have already addressed the
operation and thermal behavior of PHPs. Delil [4]
presented a survey on pulsating/oscillating devices
suitable to be used in microgravity and supergravity
environments. Important contributions related to the
PHPs on closed loop configuration were given by
Charoensawan et al. [5], Khandekar et al. [6,7], Rittidech
et al. [8] and Tong et al. [9]. The critical issues and an
approximate operation behavior of PHPs have been
addressed by Groll and Khandekar [10]. The factors that
directly affect the PHPs operation, such as effects of
latent heat, capillary resistance, etc have been already
determined [11]. As a relatively new field, most of the
theory involved on PHPs design and operation were
derived from the classic two-phase flow theory, which
could be used as a first approach in analyzing such a
device. Evaluation of the slug/plug flow transitions are
required, with special attention to the flow pattern
transition and dynamics involved in such an application
as reduced diameters are used.
The PHP operation presents some unique charac-
teristics and a very interesting thermal behavior. One
particularity of PHP operation is that it presents thermo-
dynamics instabilities associated with the plug/slug
dynamics, even though such a dynamics is in
mechanical equilibrium. The vapor plugs formation and
collapse presents a chaotic behavior that is difficult to