International Journal of Industrial Engineering
& Technology (IJIET)
ISSN 2277-4769
Vol.2, Issue 2 Sep 2012 1-15
© TJPRC Pvt. Ltd.,
A HYBRID APPROACH BASED ON FUZZY DEA AND BSC
TO MEASURE THE EFFICIENCY OF SUPPLY CHAIN; REAL
CASE OF INDUSTRY
HAMID KAZEMKHANLOU
1
& HAMIDREZA AHADI
2
1
Graduate student of Transportation Engineering, School of Railway Engineering
Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
2
Assistant Professor, School of Railway Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technology,Tehran,
Iran
ABSTRACT
Performance evaluation plays an important role in determining faults and difficulties of any
supply chain as well as attempting to increase capabilities and improve activities. Data
envelopment analysis (DEA), as a non-parametric method, has been one of the most important and
significant management tools for measuring output or efficiency. In fact, in a real evaluation problem
input and output data of entities evaluated often fluctuate. These fluctuating data can be represented as
linguistic variables characterized by fuzzy numbers for reflecting a kind of general feeling or experience
of experts. Based on the fundamental CCR model, a fuzzy DEA model is proposed to deal with the
efficiency evaluation problem with the given fuzzy input and output data. . In this paper, we propose a
method to utilize balanced score card (BSC) as a tool for designing performance evaluation indices of an
supply chain. The integrated BSC-FDEA has been applied as an empirical case for Iranian dairy industry
supply chains and the results are analyzed.
KEYWORDS: Data envelopment analysis (DEA); Balanced scorecard; Performance Evaluation; Fuzzy
DEA; Fuzzy linear programming
INTRODUCTION
Measuring the efficiency of any supply chain has become an interesting issue among
interested researchers. Data envelopment analysis (DEA) initially proposed by Charnes et al. [3] is a non-
parametric technique for measuring and evaluating the relative efficiencies of a set of entities, called
decision-making units (DMUs), with the common inputs and outputs. Examples include school, hospital,
library and, more recently, whole economic and society systems, in which outputs and inputs are always
multiple in character. Most of DEA papers make an assumption that input and output data are crisp ones
without any variation. In fact, inputs and outputs of DMUs are ever-changeful. For example, for
evaluating operation efficiencies of airlines, seat-kilometers available, cargo-kilometers available, fuel
and labor are regarded as the inputs and passenger-kilometers performed as the output [5]. It is common
sense that these inputs and output are easy to change because of weather, season, operating state and so