Journalof Infection (1998) 36, 303-306
Tuberculosis is the Commonest Cause of Pneumonia Requiring
Hospitalization During Hajj (Pilgrimage to Makkah)
A. Alzeer .1, A. Mashlah 2, N. Fakim 3, N. AI-Sugair a, M. AI-Hedaithy 1, S. AI-Majed 1 and
G. Jamjoom ~
1Department of Medicine, 4Department of Microbiology, King Saud University, Riyadh, 2King Abdulaziz Hospital, Makkah,
3A1-Noor Specialist Hospital, Makkah, SChest Hospital, Taif, Saudi Arabia
The diagnosis and treatment of pneumonia in mass gathering situations is a medical challenge, requiring prompt
decision making and knowledge of the aetiology.
We studied cases of pneumonia admitted to two hospitals during the 1994 pilgrimage (Hail) season to Makkah.
Sixty-four patients were enrolled in the study, of which 47 (75%) were men with a mean age of 63 years
(range 21-91). Nearly all were from developing countries. Diagnosis was established in 46 patients (72%) with
Mgcobacterium tuberculosis being the commonest causative organism (20%), followed by Gram-negative bacilli
(18.8%). Streptococcus pneumoniae accounted for only 10%, with Legionella pneumophilia, Mycoplasma pneu-
moniae, and viruses accounting each for 6%. The main finding of this study is that M. tuberculosis is a common
cause of pneumonia under these unusual "extreme circumstances". Its presentation was acute and indistinguishable
from pyogenic pneumonia. Thirty-one per cent of tuberculous cases had upper lobe involvement, 54% lower lobe,
and 15% multi-lobar. This was similar to the radiographic features in non-tuberculous pneumonia cases. All but
one patient with tuberculosis recovered following the administration of first-line anti-tuberculous drugs. The total
mortality was 17%.
The preponderance of M. tuberculosis and Gram-negative bacteria over S. pneumoniae may reflect the prior use
of amoxyciflin and the effect of exhaustion, malnutrition, and old age.
Introduction
The causative organisms and clinical picture of com-
munity-acquired pneumonia under normal social cir-
cumstances are well defined. A few case reports and
studies have suggested that pneumonia has a different
picture and aetiology under what was called "extreme
circumstances ''1 in "disaster regions ''2 and camps in de-
veloping countries. 2' 3 The combination of overcrowding,
exhaustion, and poverty has resulted in a high incidence
of pneumonia generally, and in particular, outbreaks of
Mycoplasma pneumonia< and a "caseous" form of pul-
monary tuberculosis characterized by severe systemic
effects and high mycobacterial load. 1
Pilgrimage to Mald¢ah in Arabia is a unique phe-
nomenon with important medical and epidemiological
implications which could serve as a model for a setting
of "extreme circumstances". Millions of pilgrims, mostly
elderly subjects from poor countries with a high pre-
valence of infectious diseases like tuberculosis, 4 follow air
* Address all correspondence to: A. Alzeer, Consultant Pulmonologist
& Intensivist, Department of Medicine (38), College of Medicine, King
Saud University, P.O. Box 18321, Riyadh 11415, Saudi Arabia.
Accepted for publication 25 September 1997.
travel by gathering under crowded conditions (mostly
tents) to perform physically-exhausting religious rites.
The pilgrimage usually lasts for a few weeks. Although
heat stroke in association with adult respiratory distress
syndrome and disseminated intravascular coagulopathy
are the best described complications of pilgrimage, s a few
reports and anecdotal evidence point to a high incidence
of meningitis 6 and respiratory tract infection complicated
by high mortality. We decided, therefore, to conduct a
study to determine the aetiology, clinical features and
outcome of severe pneumonia requiring hospital ad-
mission among pilgrims to Makkah.
Materials and Methods
This cross-sectional study was carried out in two main
referral hospitals in the Makkah area (A1-Noor Specialist
Hospital and King Abdulaziz Hospital) during the whole
of the pilgrimage season, extending between 3 and 28
May 1994. All pilgrims admitted to hospital with pneu-
monia were included. Nearly all were referred from hajj
camps.
For the purpose of the study, pneumonia was defined
as an acute episode associated with respiratory symptoms
0163-4453/98/030303 + 04 $12.00/0 © 1998 The British Infection Society