© Kamla-Raj 2014 J Soc Sci, 40(2): 185-192 (2014)
Historical Reflections on the role of Politicised Collective
Identity Groupings against the African National Congress (ANC)
Led Government in South Africa: An Un(realistic)
Challenge to Democracy?
Chitja Twala
Department of History, Faculty of the Humanities, University of the Free State,
Bloemfontein, South Africa
E-mail: twalacm@ufs.ac.za
KEYWORDS Local Government. Poverty. Councillors. Politics. Social Conflicts. Community Protests
ABSTRACT The local state is important for understanding the social context within which social conflict and
contestation occur. Therefore, the local arena, with its specific historical development and local political scene
should be factored into any analysis of social conflict and protest. The study acknowledges that most social
movements and community protests have their base in the locality and are often aimed at challenging particular
aspects within this geographic space. Furthermore, the study attempts to reflect on whether or not community
protests in South Africa are aimed at challenging the newly established democracy or not? In this study, the author
contends that in one way or another community protests are politically motivated with the purpose to a certain
extent destabilising the ruling African National Congress (ANC) in South Africa. In providing a historical reflection
on these protests, the study acknowledges the fact that there is a link between community protests and the
complaints against the issue of poverty escalation in South Africa. In the socially stratified South African society,
the problem of closing the gap between the haves and the have nots is a contested terrain among political parties,
politicised collective identity groupings as well as those individuals contesting the ANC’s rule and governance in
South Africa. Although there are other reasons for contesting the ANC’s rule and governance, community based or
social issues are mainly used as springboards to challenge the ANC in terms of the delivery of services are
concerned. The final analysis of the study shows that in the main, the instigators of these community protests are
politicised collective groupings with certain sociological and political identities.
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, community protests, as one
of the challenges faced by the ANC’s govern-
ment, have been subjected to continuous scru-
tiny by both academics and political scientists
alike. The study acknowledges the achievement
of political liberation by South Africa as a mea-
sure of democracy and the process of signifi-
cant de-racialisation since 1994. Almost 20 years
into the democratic dispensation, South Africa
under the ANC government still experience com-
munity protests in the majority of the country’s
townships. This is sometimes due to deep so-
cial inequalities linked with what is believed to
be an unequal distribution of resources. The
South African Constitution stresses the notion
of cooperative governance and identifies the
local sphere of governance as one arena crucial
for service delivery. More community protests
were reported in the first half of 2009 than in any
previous year, accounting for almost a quarter
of all protests since 1994 with the Western Cape
and Gauteng provinces being the hardest hit.
Therefore, the study explores the nexus between
politically identifiable collective groupings and
the perpetuation of community protests in South
Africa. Thus, it questions the synergy between
the two; either in attempts to destabilise the
governance of the ANC or having genuine com-
munity concerns which arguably the ruling par-
ty is failing to address. Furthermore, the study
briefly discusses the role of such groupings and
their applied strategies in posing social as well
as political challenges to the ANC as the ruling
party in South Africa. The study aims to ad-
dress the following critical questions: What are
the main characteristics of community protests?
What are the causes of community protests?
Why is there any ideological juxtaposition be-
tween service delivery by the ANC and commu-
nity protests? In what ways do the history and
culture of struggle against apartheid influence
community protests in the post-apartheid South
Africa? How is the ANC dealing with communi-
ty protests?